Challenges and Opportunities for Integrated Reporting in Latin American SMEs: Insights From Business Practice

Desafíos y oportunidades del reporte integrado en pymes latinoamericanas: perspectivas desde la práctica empresarial

DOI10.22430/10.22430/24223182.3493 Logotecnologicas PDF Table Figure

Received: May 18, 2025
Accepted: December 23, 2025

How to cite / Cómo referenciar
Vélez Ramírez, R. A., Marco-Fondevila, M., y Moneva, J. M. (2026). Challenges and Opportunities for Integrated Reporting in Latin American SMEs: Insights From Business Practice. Revista CEA, 12(28), e3493. https://doi.org/10.22430/24223182.3493

 

Abstract

Objective: To identify the main obstacles and opportunities faced by Latin American SMEs in implementing Integrated Reporting (ir)—a strategic response to current social and environmental challenges that facilitates the disclosure of responsible and sustainable initiatives within the business sector.
Design/Methodology: This mixed-methods study was conducted in six Latin American countries: Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Mexico, and Peru. Data were collected through a survey administered to 100 business leaders, scholars, and researchers, complemented by a semi-structured interview with 27 highly regarded professionals from across the region.
Findings: The study revealed that ir is not exclusive to global corporations. Latin American smes also engage in sustainable strategies, including financing social projects, paying for green products, and pursuing environmental certifications. However, 71% of these enterprises fail to apply social or environmental reporting standards, mainly due to limited methodological knowledge, perceived high implementation costs, lack of qualified personnel, and absence of legal requirements. The results also showed that enterprises with more than ten years of operation have a greater capacity to establish csr policies. Finally, there is a direct relationship between csr and ir —the former provides the content and the latter offers the structure for efficiently communicating value creation to stakeholders.
Conclusions: Despite its pitfalls, ir functions as a dynamic instrument that integrates csr principles and provides a holistic view of organizational performance, facilitating communication with stakeholders and contributing to building a more sustainable future.
Originality: This study highlights how smes can demonstrate value creation and legitimacy to stakeholders through ir. It also opens new avenues for research, such as the analysis of Latin American enterprises and their impact on investors’ decision-making.

Keywords: sustainability standards, smes, integrated reporting, Corporate Social Responsibility, sustainability.
JEL codes: M21, M41, M48.


Highlights

  • It analyzes ir from business practice in five Latin American countries.
  • It shows that some SMEs implement csr principles but adopt ir only partially.
  • It points to the need for simplified and progressive reporting frameworks tailored to Latin American smes.
  • It evidences a gap between the sustainability discourse and the actual incorporation of ir in smes.
  • It highlights the role of ir as a tool for legitimization and sustainable value creation.
  • Resumen

    Objetivo: Identificar los principales obstáculos y oportunidades a los que se enfrentan las pymes latinoamericanas a la hora de implementar el reporte integrado (ri), una respuesta estratégica a los retos sociales y medioambientales actuales que facilita la divulgación de iniciativas responsables y sostenibles en el sector empresarial.
    Metodología: esta investigación de enfoque mixto, que tuvo como población objetivo seis países latinoamericanos: Argentina, Brasil, Colombia, Ecuador, México y Perú, se fundamentó en la aplicación de 100 encuestas a empresarios, académicos e investigadores, complementadas con 27 entrevistas semiestructuradas realizadas a profesionales de reconocido prestigio latinoamericano.
    Resultados: el estudio reveló que el reporte integrado no solo es para empresas globales; las pymes latinoamericanas también generan estrategias sostenibles como financiamiento en proyectos sostenibles, pago por productos sostenibles y certificaciones ambientales. Sin embargo, hay barreras importantes: el 71 % de las empresas no aplican estándares de balance social o ambiental, principalmente por desconocimiento de metodologías, percepción de altos costos de implementación, falta de personal calificado y ausencia de obligatoriedad legal. La investigación demuestra que las empresas con más de 10 años de trayectoria tienen mayor capacidad para establecer políticas de Responsabilidad Social Empresarial (rse). Finalmente, existe una relación directa entre la rse y el reporte integrado: la primera proporciona el contenido y el segundo ofrece la estructura para comunicar eficazmente la creación de valor a los grupos de interés.
    Conclusiones: el reporte integrado funciona como instrumento dinámico que integra principios de responsabilidad social empresarial y proporciona una visión holística del desempeño organizacional, facilitando la comunicación con los stakeholders y contribuyendo a la construcción de un futuro más sostenible.
    Originalidad: este estudio es clave para que las pymes mundiales demuestren su creación de valor y legitimidad ante los stakeholders. También abre nuevas líneas de investigación, como el análisis de empresas latinoamericanas y su impacto en las decisiones de los inversores.

    Palabras clave: estándares de sostenibilidad, pymes, reporte integrado, responsabilidad social empresarial, sostenibilidad.
    códigos JEL: M21, M41, M48.


    Highlights

  • Analiza el reporte integrado desde la práctica empresarial en cinco países latinoamericanos.
  • Evidencia que algunas pymes implementan responsabilidad social empresarial, pero adoptan el reporte integrado de forma parcial.
  • Señala la necesidad de marcos de reporte simplificados y progresivos para las pymes Latinoamericanas.
  • Evidencia una brecha entre el discurso de sostenibilidad y la implementación del reporte integrado en las pymes.
  • Destaca el rol del reporte integrado como herramienta de legitimación y creación de valor sostenible.
  • 1. INTRODUCTION

    Currently, major social and environmental challenges such as climate change require the business sector—the main driver of economic development—to play a key role in mitigating environmental damage and reducing poverty through the implementation of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) practices (Monteiro et al., 2015). From an accounting perspective, several mechanisms support the disclosure of information that contributes to the legitimization and acceptance of organizational results, while also highlighting the need for dialogue and for reports based on internationally recognized standards.

    Against this backdrop, standards such as the sustainability reports of the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI, 2002), the Integrated Reporting (IR) framework proposed by the International Integrated Reporting Council (IIRC, 2013), and the sustainability- and climate-related International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) S1 and S2 (Deloitte, 2024; IFRS Foundation, 2023) incorporate intangible elements that are not traditionally captured in financial reporting but are essential for the creation of business and organizational value (Ficco & Luna Valenzuela, 2021). These tools offer a comprehensive solution to the limitations of conventional financial reports (Busco et al., 2019).

    Around the globe, academic and professional interest in ir has increased rapidly, recognizing its importance for creating value over time (Abeywardana et al., 2021). However, criticism persists, particularly regarding the difficulty of establishing links between the various financial and non-financial reports (Jensen & Berg, 2012). Changes in reporting practices have been introduced as a result of active pressure from stakeholders, who demand more transparent and comprehensive accountability. Although advances in governance reporting have expanded the possibilities for the evolution of non-financial reporting, they have also favored a fragmented view that hinders the integration of related information (Halid et al., 2021).

    Voluntary disclosure of corporate assets has gained relevance among enterprises and governance bodies as an alternative means of communicating actions to stakeholders. Financial statements, along with their disclosures and annexes, contain information on the enterprise situation and performance, revealing various aspects of the value creation process (Ficco et al., 2021). Despite this progress, standardized, clearly defined, and globally accepted regulatory frameworks are still needed. Accordingly, Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SMEs) in Latin America continuously seek guiding instruments that enable them to prepare non-financial information and determine the value they create internally.

    Thus, this article aims to provide Latin American smes with the tools required to apply the European Common Reporting Framework. To this end, it identifies the challenges these firms face and offers insights into the future development of a reporting model that reflects their relationship with csr practices and value creation, thereby facilitating managerial decision-making through relevant indicators.

    This paper is organized into six sections. Following this introduction, Section 2 outlines the historical and conceptual background of ir, from the nineteenth century to the present. Section 3 describes the mixed-methods methodology employed, including the data collection instruments and the sample used. Sections 4 and 5 present the results and discussion in relation to the hypotheses concerning the application of ir in Latin American smes. Finally, Section 6 offers the study’s conclusions, along with its limitations and recommendations for future research.

    2. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

    To address ir, it is necessary to deeply understand the theoretical frameworks that explain the way organizations legitimize their actions, respond to stakeholder demands, and adapt to regulatory and institutional environments. The integration of these conceptual perspectives is key to analyzing how enterprises, particularly smes, communicate their value creation process around the six capitals defined by the iirc (financial, manufactured, intellectual, human, social and relationship, and natural) over different time horizons. In this regard, the legitimacy theory, the stakeholder theory, and the institutional theory offer complementary foundations for managing the harmonization, quality, and credibility of reporting in response to social, regulatory, and market pressures (Masiero et al., 2023).

    Figure 1 illustrates a cyclical and progressive model for implementing ir in Latin American smes, highlighting its continuous and dynamic nature. The diagram shows how the adoption of ir evolves gradually according to organizational capacities and institutional context, integrating strategy, sustainability, and value creation.

    Legitimacy Theory

    The legitimacy theory holds that organizational continuity depends on social acceptance and alignment with values shared by society. According to Weber (1964) and Deegan (2002), organizations seek to maintain consistency between their actions and social expectations for retaining their license to operate. When legitimacy issues arise due to environmental impacts, social conflicts, or reputational crises, enterprises tend to intensify both symbolic and substantive disclosure to restore public trust. In this sense, ir functions as a legitimization mechanism, linking the business model to risks, opportunities, results, and governance. However, this theory also warns of a risk: the possibility of a disconnect between discourse and practice when disclosure responds more to symbolic pressures than to genuine transformations.

    Figure 1. Theoretical articulation of integrated reporting
    Figura 1. Integración teórica del reporte integrado
    Source: Authors’ own work.
    Stakeholder Theory

    Formulated by Freeman and McVea (2001), the stakeholder theory conceives of the organization as a network of relationships among internal and external stakeholders, including investors, employees, regulators, communities, and civil society, which influence and are influenced by corporate decisions. This perspective emphasizes the need to meet stakeholders’ reporting expectations regarding transparency, comparability of metrics, and integration of financial and non-financial performance (Laplume et al., 2008). The materiality process, as a pillar of ir, reflects this orientation by prioritizing topics that create value for stakeholders and organizational sustainability. Nonetheless, this theory recognizes that tensions may arise from conflicts of interest and power asymmetries, which can condition the disclosure agenda and the balance among stakeholders.

    Institutional Theory

    Rooted in the work of Veblen (Figueras & Morero, 2013) and further developed by DiMaggio and Powell (1983), the institutional theory argues that organizations tend to adopt structures and practices that reflect socially legitimized standards and rules. These, in turn, give rise to processes of coercive, normative, and mimetic isomorphism. Regulatory frameworks, technical standards, and professional networks such as auditing or accounting associations promote progressive homogenization of ir formats and indicators. According to Meyer and Rowan (1977), the global spread of ir is largely explained by institutional pressures to regulate, professionalize, and replicate successful practices. However, such adoption may become ceremonial if organizations lack sufficient resources or capacities for effective implementation.

    Taken together, these three theories offer insights into how legitimacy socially justifies disclosure, how stakeholders define their relational and accountability dimensions, and how institutions establish the frameworks that structure and standardize ir practices. Their interaction positions ir as a tool not only for communication purposes but also for strategic management and sustainability.

    Historical Evolution and International Integrated Reporting Frameworks

    Since the mid-twentieth century, accounting information has undergone a gradual transformation toward the incorporation of social, environmental, and ethical variables. In the 1970s, traditional financial statements began to be supplemented with social reports (Fifka, 2012), which are considered precursors to current sustainability reporting standards.

    The Jenkins Report, prepared by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (1994), was a significant milestone because it proposed the disclosure of non-financial information as an essential complement to traditional accounting. Along the same lines, the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) expanded the informational scope of financial statements by integrating non-financial aspects, thereby laying the foundations for ir.

    The iasb has maintained a traditional ir philosophy by articulating accounting and legal standards. In this sense, non-financial information is presented as a complement to financial disclosures. One of the most generally recognized and applied models in social and environmental reporting is the Sustainability Reporting Framework of the gri (Fortanier et al., 2011). Since the late 1990s, this set of standards has become the most widely used to ensure transparency and structure in the disclosure of sustainability information (Bebbington et al., 2012).

    Simultaneously, initiatives such as the Red Española del Pacto Mundial (2018) and the iso 26000 standard on social responsibility (International Organization for Standardization [ISO], 2010) have promoted csr through voluntary guidelines aimed at respecting human rights, ethical conduct, decent work, and environmental protection. The following historical overview serves as a baseline for understanding the development of these reporting practices.

    South Africa became a pioneer by making ir mandatory in 2010 for companies listed on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (Abhayawansa, 2014), setting an important precedent in terms of transparency and accountability. In the United States, the creation of the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB) in 2011 led to the formulation of 77 standards to assess the impact of sustainability on financial performance (Morrós Ribera, 2014).

    In Europe, Directive 2014/95/ue—issued by the European Parliament and the Council of the European Union—required the inclusion of non-financial information in the management reports of public-interest entities (Parlamento Europeo & Consejo de la Unión Europea, 1995). More recently, the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (csrd) has extended these obligations (Lefebvre, 2023), establishing a standardized format for reporting social and environmental risks, opportunities, and impacts. This directive reinforces the European Union’s leadership in promoting corporate sustainability through the integration of financial and non-financial information (European Commission, 2025).

    Furthermore, the merger between the sasb and the iirc gave rise to the Value Reporting Foundation (2024), whose purpose is to provide a comprehensive framework for measuring, managing, and communicating corporate value (Sust4ain, 2021). Likewise, the World Federation of Exchanges has led joint initiatives to encourage listed companies to disclose sustainability information, strengthening the role of capital markets as guarantors of responsible corporate reporting (Rivera-Arrubla et al., 2016; Villanueva García et al., 2015).

    Based on the above, Table 1 summarizes the historical evolution of corporate reporting models, highlighting the transition from exclusively financial statements to integrated frameworks that articulate economic, social, and environmental dimensions. This advancement reflects changes in stakeholder demands and the growing recognition of sustainability as a central component in the creation of organizational value.

    Table 1. Evolution of reporting on financial and non-financial information
    Tabla 1. Evolución del reporting sobre información financiera y no financiera
    DecadeType of ReportCharacteristic
    Before the 1970sFinancial statementsPredominantly financial dimension
    1970s–1980sReports focused on financial informationFinancial dimension with little social and environmental information
    Isolated reports on social or environmental informationOne sustainability dimension (social or environmental)
    1990sIsolated reports on financial informationFinancial dimension
    Specialized sustainability reports that combine social and environmental informationTwo sustainability dimensions (social and environmental)
    2000sInitiatives to present sustainability and financial information in a global reportPredominance of the financial dimension and emergence of non-financial information
    PresentA single integrated reportThree balanced sustainability dimensions (financial, social, and environmental)
    Source: Authors’ own work based on Hahn and Kühnen (2013).

    In summary, both theory and practice configure the conceptual framework of ir. From a theoretical perspective, it is based on legitimacy, stakeholders, and the institutions that shape the dynamics of corporate disclosure. From a practical point of view, it has been developed through global standards—gri, sasb, csrd, iso 26000, Value Reporting Foundation—that aim to harmonize transparency, comparability, and accountability. In this regard, ir not only communicates value creation but also strengthens stakeholder confidence and contributes to organizational sustainability through the articulation of financial, social, and environmental performance (López & Coelho, 2018).

    3. METHODOLOGY

    This study employed a mixed-methods approach with a descriptive and explanatory scope to identify the main obstacles and opportunities faced by Latin American smes when implementing ir in the regional business context. To this end, it combined quantitative and qualitative techinques through a triangular methodological design that integrated three phases: literature review, surveys, and semi-structured interviews.

    In the first phase, the literature review centered on ir and sustainability. The search was conducted in two internationally recognized scientific databases, namely Scopus and Web of Science, following the guidelines proposed by Pranckutė (2021). The inclusion criteria were restricted to articles published in indexed scientific journals, written in Spanish or English, and focusing on the areas of administration, finance, accounting, and economics. The process yielded 250 documents that formed the basis for constructing the theoretical and conceptual framework of the study (Vélez Ramírez et al., 2024). Figure 2 illustrates the methodological stages of the study, from literature search and selection to the application of data collection instruments.

    Figure 2. Methodology for analyzing the implementation of integrated reporting
    Figura 2. Metodología para analizar la implementación del reporte integrado
    Source: Created by the authors.

    In the second phase, a structured questionnaire was administered to a target population of 900 participants, comprising entrepreneurs, scholars, consultants, and researchers linked to the Latin American business sector. A total of 100 valid responses were obtained, exceeding the 96 required to guarantee a 90 % confidence level and an 8 % margin of error. The instrument consisted of 17 questions inquiring about the application of csr principles, the perceived benefits of ir, the barriers identified, and the existence of management indicators. Responses were received from six Latin American countries: Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, Ecuador, Mexico, and Peru, which ensured regional representativeness and allowed for the recognition of common patterns and contextual differences in the implementation of ir.

    The third phase involved the collection of qualitative information through ten semi-structured interviews with business representatives, government officials, and field experts. The interviewees were from Argentina, Colombia, Chile, Ecuador, and Peru, which provided a diversity of perspectives on the challenges, opportunities, and barriers associated with the adoption of ir in smes across the region.

    Finally, the data analysis was designed in an integrated manner to test the formulated hypotheses. Information gathered from the three sources—literature review, surveys, and interviews—was triangulated. This methodological approach made it possible to contrast theoretical perspectives with business practices, strengthen the validity and robustness of the results, and offer a holistic understanding of the phenomenon.

    4. RESULTS

    The results of this study provide deeper insights about the level of progress, appropriation, and challenges of ir in Latin America, particularly in the context of smes. Consequently, the findings are presented in an integrated manner, articulating quantitative and qualitative evidence and establishing connections with the contemporary literature on corporate sustainability, business transparency, and international sustainability reporting standards.

    The evidence suggests that the region is undergoing a process of institutional and organizational maturation around sustainability. Although ir has not yet reached significant levels of adoption among Latin American smes, clear signs of progress point to growing incorporation of non-financial reporting practices, sustainability-oriented strategic thinking, and long-term value management.

    Global Context and Relevance of Integrated Reporting

    Over the past 15 years, ir has evolved from a voluntary initiative promoted by international organizations into a global benchmark for the strategic disclosure of corporate performance (Abhayawansa et al., 2019). The creation of the iirc and its subsequent integration into the Value Reporting Foundation marked a turning point that consolidated ir as a key mechanism for communicating value creation in the short, medium, and long terms (Beck et al., 2017).

    By 2025, the number of organizations worldwide adopting the ir framework exceeded 2,500, representing a 35 % increase compared to 2022 (Value Reporting Foundation, 2024). This rise is closely related to:

    1. the consolidation of stricter regulatory frameworks in Europe (such as the csrd).
    2. the issuance of global standards by the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB, 2024).
    3. pressure from institutional investors demanding clear information on climate and sustainability risks.
    4. growing expectations from consumers, financial institutions, and civil society.

    These factors have contributed to an environment where non-financial disclosure is no longer merely a reputational concern but a strategic and legal requirement, particularly for organizations with international exposure (Value Reporting Foundation, 2024). However, significant limitations remain because many enterprises continue to present partial or overly positive reports, minimizing their negative environmental or social impacts (Chiba et al., 2018). Recent international regulations, driven by the ISSB (2024), seek to correct these asymmetries by demanding more objective disclosure of the adverse effects of business activity, especially in relation to climate change.

    Stakeholder Engagement Practices

    The results show that Latin American smes have begun to incorporate sustainability-oriented practices in their interaction with key stakeholders, particularly customers and suppliers. Although these practices do not in themselves constitute ir, they do represent a step toward integrated thinking, one of the pillars of ir.

    The data presented in Figure 3 reveal that:

    1. 47.1 % of companies use csr to enhance their product pricing, reflecting that offering healthy and sustainable products increases consumers' willingness to pay a premium for them.
    2. 5.9 % of enterprises finance third-party sustainable projects, suggesting the presence of strategic alliances linked to sustainability.
    3. 17.6 % prioritize environmentally friendly products, indicating the integration of sustainability criteria into the supply chain.
    4. 29.4 % pursue environmental certifications, which implies an explicit interest in strengthening institutional legitimacy.

    These practices are aligned with ir principles, which propose that value creation is a relational and dynamic process constructed jointly by the organization and its environment.

    Figure 3. Stakeholder-related practices
    Figura 3. Aspectos que aplican los grupos de interés
    Source: Authors’ own work based on survey data.

    Additionally, these practices were found to be more developed in enterprises with over ten years of operation, suggesting that organizational consolidation is a relevant predictor of the adoption of sustainability-oriented practices.

    Evolution of the Strategic Dimension in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises

    This study revealed a transition in the way Latin American smes approach strategic management. Although these enterprises have historically been characterized by reactive operations and low levels of formalization, the information compiled in Figure 4 shows emerging changes in the following key areas:

    1. 26.4 % make individual or group decisions, suggesting that strategic management remains concentrated in a few individuals within the organization.
    2. 15.8 % track green purchases, indicating a growing integration of sustainable criteria in procurement decisions.
    3. 13.8 % use risk and opportunity matrices, reflecting greater awareness of the need to anticipate scenarios and manage uncertainty.
    4. 13.4 % prioritize resource allocation, evidencing efforts to plan the efficient use of available capital.
    5. 11.6 % conduct environmental analysis, signaling an orientation toward understanding the competitive and sectoral context.
    6. 9.3 % monitor competitors, suggesting an increasing interest in market positioning.
    7. 8.0 % develop improvement plans, implying an organizational culture oriented toward continuous improvement.
    8. 1.7 % participate in business fairs, indicating that external networking and commercial visibility remain underdeveloped practices
    Figure 4. Management activities of enterprises
    Figura 4. Actividades de gestión de las empresas
    Source: Authors’ own work based on survey data.

    Although incipient, these activities reveal that smes are incorporating management tools typically used by more sophisticated and professionalized organizations. This behavior is consistent with previous studies suggesting that the formalization of strategic processes is a prerequisite for adopting non-financial reporting and advanced corporate information models. Notably, smes engaging in strategic activities are more likely to implement Environmental, Social, and Governance (esg) practices, laying the groundwork for the eventual introduction of ir.

    Organizational History and Internal Capacities

    Business history emerges as a determining factor. Figure 5 shows that 67 % of enterprises have been operating for over ten years, and 22 % for more than 5 years, which has a positive influence on the adoption of sustainability models due to:

    1. accumulation of organizational experience.
    2. greater administrative and financial stability.
    3. expansion of external networks and social fabric.
    4. increased institutional pressure to comply with emerging standards.
    Figure 5. Age of enterprises
    Figura 5. Edad de las empesas
    Source: Authors’ own work based on survey data.

    However, as shown in Figure 6, nearly 70.37 % of companies implement some form of social or environmental reporting, reflecting significant progress in sustainable reporting culture. However, the remaining 29.63 % have yet to do so, highlighting the persistent gap between interest and capacity — a recurring finding in regional studies by the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (2024), the GRI (2002), and the World Business Council for Sustainable Development.

    Figure 6. Application of integrated reporting models
    Figura 6. Aplicación de modelos de reporte integrado
    Source: Authors’ own work based on survey data.

    The most common reasons for not reporting include:

    1. absence of standardized processes
    2. budget constraints
    3. lack of personnel trained in sustainability and reporting
    4. perception that these models are designed for large enterprises.
    Structural Barriers to the Adoption of Integrated Reporting

    Figure 7 synthesizes the main barriers faced by Latin American smes in adopting non-financial reporting and Integrated Reporting (IR). The surveys and interviews conducted with representatives of these organizations made it possible to identify several concrete obstacles that explain why they have yet to incorporate either practice into their management processes.

    Figure 7. Barriers to non-financial and integrated reporting
    Figura 7. Barreras a modelos no financieros y reporte integrado
    Source: Authors’ own work.

    Lack of methodological knowledge leads the findings, accounting for 32 % of responses. Business owners and experts alike acknowledged having no clear understanding of how to develop this type of report, with several noting that, faced with this uncertainty, they resort to applying their own internal models that do not necessarily align with recognized international standards. This finding reveals that the barrier is not a lack of willingness, but rather the absence of accessible, context-specific technical guidance.

    At 28 %, the perceived high cost of implementation ranks second. Across both instruments, a recurring view emerged: these processes demand financial resources that SMEs are simply not in a position to allocate, particularly when no legal obligation exists to justify the investment.

    Lack of specialized personnel, at 22 %, occupies third place. SMEs typically operate with lean teams managing multiple responsibilities simultaneously, making it difficult to assign staff to processes that also require specific technical expertise in non-financial reporting matters.

    Finally, the absence of mandatory regulatory frameworks concentrates 18 % of responses. Several participants were explicit on this point: management interest in adopting these models tends to surface only when a binding legal requirement is in place. This, combined with the fact that non-financial reporting remains unregulated across a significant number of countries in the region, confirms that the normative environment continues to be a decisive factor in whether implementation moves forward or stalls indefinitely.

    Taken together, the results obtained through the applied instruments demonstrate that these barriers do not operate independently. They form an interconnected cycle in which weak regulation diminishes institutional commitment, limited knowledge constrains the capacity to act, and the scarcity of both human and financial resources ultimately brings any meaningful progress to a halt. Overcoming them will require not only political will and an ethical, holistic vision of the environmental and social challenges confronting the region, but also a sustained and genuine commitment from academia, the public sector, and organizations themselves to build the foundational conditions that make ir adoption a realistic and viable path for Latin American SMEs.

    Human Capital Practices and Internal Sustainability

    Internally, as illustrated in Figure 8, human capital practices show significant progress toward more sustainable labor models, including:

    1. Performance bonuses (31.6 %)
    2. Teleworking (19.3 %)
    3. Government benefits (16.4 %)
    4. Education allowance (14.2 %)
    5. Food allowance (10.5 8201%)
    6. Flexible working hours (8 %)
    Figure 8. Human capital practices in enterprises
    Figura 8. Recursos humanos aplicados en la empresa
    Source: Authors’ own work based on survey data.

    Performance bonuses stand out at 31.6 %, indicating that financial incentives remain the most widely used tool for motivating and retaining staff. This is followed by teleworking at 19.3 %, whose presence reflects the adaptation that many companies were compelled to undertake in response to the changes brought about by the pandemic, a practice that some have since maintained as a permanent part of their management model.

    Government benefits (16.4 %) and education allowances (14.2 %) rank third and fourth respectively, showing that a portion of these organizations take advantage of existing regulatory frameworks and invest in training as a pathway for human talent development. With a smaller share, food allowances (10.5 %) address workers' basic needs, while flexible working hours (8.0 %) record the lowest adoption rate, a finding worth highlighting given their widely recognized influence on employee well-being and overall productivity.

    The results show that Latin American SMEs tend to prioritize direct financial incentives over flexibility and development strategies, aspects that, in the medium and long term, carry greater weight in organizational sustainability and the quality of life of their workforce.

    Qualitative Findings: Insights from Latin American Experts

    The experts interviewed agreed that:

    1. ir is conceptually well understood but poorly implemented in the region.
    2. many organizations produce “integrated reports” without complying with iirc principles.
    3. a descriptive approach prevails over a strategic one.
    4. adoption is higher among benefit corporations, certified b organizations, and exporters.
    5. smes lack clear regulatory incentives.
    6. there is a gap between theoretical knowledge and technical capabilities.

    The interviewees emphasized the need for:

    1. specialized training in sustainability and esg reporting.
    2. simplified standards for smes (as proposed by the ifrs Foundation in its 2024–2027 agenda).
    3. incorporation of integrated thinking in universities and business associations.
    4. stronger institutional pressure, especially from the financial system.

    Overall, the results indicate that, in Latin America, ir is evolving from a declarative to a strategic approach. Although adoption among smes is still limited, signs of progress are evident in terms of:

    1. greater awareness of sustainability.
    2. professionalization of business management.
    3. increased strategic interaction with stakeholders.
    4. regulatory advances in specific countries.
    5. emerging processes of risk and human capital management.

    Eventually, the consolidation of ir in the region will depend on factors such as:

    1. institutional strengthening in business regulation.
    2. internal technical training in reporting methodologies.
    3. reduction of economic and technological gaps.
    4. dissemination of models adapted to smes.
    5. DISCUSSION

    The implementation of ir is a strategic mechanism that benefits both internal management and the external positioning of organizations because it coherently articulates economic, social, and environmental information. In this regard, Table 2 provides a comparative overview of the evolution and scope of the main sustainability reporting models, showing how traditional approaches focused on isolated dimensions have gradually led to more comprehensive frameworks. Unlike previous standards—such as those developed by the International Association for Bridge and Structural Engineers (IBASE, 2007), the Latin European–American Integration Committee (CILEA, 2013), the Spanish Association of Accounting and Business Administration (AECA, ), the International Labour Organization (ILO), or the GRI—IR offers a holistic vision. It combines strategy, business model, governance, and performance; and it establishes itself as a key instrument for value creation and communication in the long term (Caballero Caballero & Balaguer Vegas, 1987).

    Table 2. Comparison of sustainability reporting models
    Tabla 2. Comparación de informes de sostenibilidad
    IBASECILEA (2013)ILOIARSE (n.d.)AECA (2004-2015)GRIIR
    ECONOMIC
    Net income
    Gross sales
    Net sales
    Social and environmental investment
    Value added created
    Direct economic value created
    Strategy and analysis
    Gross income
    Total value added
    Investment income
    External capital
    Employee compensation
    Operating expenses
    Business model
    Gross payroll
    Taxes paid to government
    Economic value distributed
    Equity
    State ownership
    Community investments
    Performance
    SOCIAL
    Internal social indicators
    Social and labor characteristics
    Human resources
    External capital payment
    Culture
    Organizational profile
    Corporate governance
    Food allowance
    Social services
    Health
    Undistributed earnings
    Training
    Operational structure
    Risks and opportunities
    Private pension
    Integration and development
    Education
    Contributions to society
    Professional development
    Infrastructure investments
    Resource strategy
    ENVIRONMENTAL
    Occupational health
    Internal operations
    Organizational culture
    Value-added statement
    Childcare services
    Markets served
    Organizational description
    Personal protective equipment
    Environmental services
    Profit sharing
    Environmental investment
    Employee benefits
    Organizational size
    Future prospects
    Workplace safety
    Environmental impact
    Other benefits
    Organizational needs
    Wellness programs
    Significant changes
    Basis of preparation
    Source: Authors’ own work based on social and environmental models.

    The evolutionary shift from reporting frameworks focused exclusively on basic economic indicators, such as net sales or gross revenue, to multidimensional systems integrating social and environmental variables responds to growing stakeholder pressure for more comprehensive and effective accountability. This transition highlights the limitations of traditional financial statements in capturing the complexity of value creation in the contemporary business context.

    In this respect, Table 3 condenses and compares the main internal and external benefits associated with the adoption of ir. It shows the way this approach strengthens not only strategic management, decision-making, and organizational governance but also transparency, reputation, and stakeholder relations.

    Table 3. Detailed comparison of internal and external benefits of integrated reporting
    Tabla 3. Comparación detallada de los beneficios internos y externos del reporte integrado
    Internal BenefitsExternal Benefits
    Improved managerial decision-makingAccountability culture
    Communication of strategic aspects across organizational levelsElimination of barriers in business areas
    Collaborative thinkingSynergy and knowledge sharing
    Increased stakeholder involvementCollaborative work in the organizational environment
    Awareness of risks and opportunitiesImprovement of organizational relations
    Enhanced organizational reputationAwareness of value creation processes
    Organizational competitivenessTrust among stakeholders
    Information on capital decisionsOpportunities for professional development
    Information on corporate governanceCreation of a quality policy
    Improvement of internal communication across functional areasImproved image, visibility, and positioning
    Summary: ir creates value both internally, by optimizing organizational management, and externally, by strengthening stakeholder relationships and improving corporate reputation.
    Source: Authors’ own work.

    The results of this study confirm that the adoption of ir has a dual impact. On the one hand, it improves decision-making processes and internal strategic coherence; on the other hand, it strengthens accountability and reputation among stakeholders. This duality shows that ir goes beyond simply communicating information—it becomes a mechanism that integrates governance, sustainability, and long-term value creation (Adams, 2015).

    Internally, evidence suggests that ir acts as a strategic alignment tool, articulating financial and non-financial objectives and promoting the dissemination of relevant information across organizational levels. This approach encourages the comprehensive management of the six capitals proposed by the iirc (financial, manufactured, intellectual, human, social and relationship, and natural), strengthening enterprises’ ability to anticipate risks, optimize resources, and guide decision-making toward sustainability.

    From an external perspective, ir contributes to consolidating a culture of transparency and accountability, improving stakeholder relations and projecting a more responsible image to the market (Rupley et al., 2017). Empirical evidence indicates a positive relationship between information transparency and financial performance within organizations that adopt this model (Value Reporting Foundation, 2024), thereby supporting the hypothesis that sustainability, when properly communicated, can become a competitive advantage.

    The findings also underscore the need to reinforce sme participation in these processes. Given that over 90 % of the global business fabric is made up of micro- and small enterprises, raising awareness of their impacts and contributions is key to moving toward a more inclusive and sustainable economic model. However, these organizations face considerable obstacles, including lack of resources, insufficient technical training, and limited knowledge of sustainability frameworks and ir.

    Against this backdrop, Figure 9 summarizes the main factors influencing the adoption of ir in Latin American smes. It compares the elements that enable its implementation, the structural barriers and challenges it faces, and the emerging opportunities derived from its incorporation. The diagram confirms the dynamic and context-dependent nature of ir in smes, demonstrating that its application depends as much on internal capacities and institutional support as on regulatory, cultural, and market conditions.

    Figure 9. Adoption of integrated reporting in Latin American small and medium-sized enterprises
    Figura 9. Adopción del reporte integrado en pymes latinoamericanas
    Source: Authors’ own work.

    This study revealed that many Latin American enterprises use the term “integrated report” but fail to apply the iirc principles. In practice, they tend to prepare partial compilations of financial, sustainability, and governance information, with little conceptual and strategic connection. This situation highlights a knowledge gap among managers regarding the essence of integrated thinking and esg criteria, which limits the transformative potential of ir.

    The promotion of a wider and more effective adoption of ir in Latin American smes requires a comprehensive approach that combines training personnel, simplifying regulatory frameworks, and creating appropriate incentives. Education in sustainability and ir should be a priority within universities, business associations, and professional bodies in order to develop capabilities in impact measurement, capital management, and value communication. Academic institutions play a crucial role in this process not only because of their training capacity but also due to their influence on the generation and dissemination of applied knowledge.

    The Latin American case, and particularly the Colombian context, shows that publicly traded companies have made progress in sustainability reporting. However, stronger regulation and greater commitment from supervisory bodies and government institutions are still needed. In unlisted companies, owners and managers remain underprepared on issues such as sustainability, circular economy, the Sustainable Development Goals, and ir (Macias & Farfán Liévano, 2017). The institutional influence of universities, civil society organizations, and government entities is therefore essential for promoting a culture of sustainability and strengthening the adoption of integrated thinking in smes.

    Likewise, one of the critical factors identified is the shortage of professionals specializing in sustainability and corporate reporting. Based on the academic experience of universities, it has been confirmed that, despite advances in outreach and training programs, professionals still have significant gaps in their technical mastery of ir and sustainable management. Thus, there is a clear need to incorporate these topics into undergraduate and continuing-education curricula, with an interdisciplinary approach that combines accounting, finance, administration, and social sciences.

    Generally speaking, this discussion confirms that ir has the potential to become a key tool for creating sustainable value and organizational legitimacy. However, its impact depends on institutional maturity, managerial commitment, and a regulatory environment that encourages transparency. Latin American smes have the strategic opportunity to adopt this model, even though this would entail reinforcing their technical capacities, improving their governance, and developing a sustainability-oriented organizational culture.

    Finally, future research should further examine the impact of ir on decision-making and governance processes and explore the possibility of moving toward a unified instrument that aligns financial and non-financial information with global standards. Addressing this challenge would contribute to improving not only the comparability and credibility of reports but also corporate reputation and confidence in enterprises, thereby consolidating ir as an effective vehicle for sustainability and business transformation in Latin America.

    6. CONCLUSIONS

    The evolutionary transition from social balance to ir has facilitated a deeper and more inclusive integration of economic, social, and environmental aspects into corporate governance. The analysis of various csr standards and practices shows that ir has become an essential tool for harmonizing these dimensions, functioning as a channel for communication between enterprises and their stakeholders. This interconnection enhances transparency and effectiveness in the disclosure of social and environmental actions and results, contributing to the common good and the construction of a more sustainable future.

    The results of this study establish a significant correlation between business strategy and performance in Latin American smes. Entrepreneurs and managers of these organizations show increasing awareness of the importance of analyzing their environment, prioritizing resource allocation, and proactively managing risks. The fact that respondents give relevance to environmental analysis (29 %) and resource allocation (18 %) weakens the belief that smes have no intention of applying a strategic approach aimed at creating long-term sustainable value.

    According to 32 % of the enterprises studied, the main obstacle to adopting non-financial reporting is their lack of familiarity with ir models. In 22 % of enterprises, this limitation is exacerbated by a shortage of qualified personnel, which highlights a relevant shortfall in internal technical capacity. Furthermore, approximately 71 % of enterprises have not yet implemented any type of social or environmental reporting, which significantly hinders their ability to create, measure, and communicate value in terms of sustainability.

    For smes, the perception of high implementation costs remains a major barrier and accounts for 28 % of non-financial reporting omissions. This situation creates a complex cycle because the enterprises that could benefit most from better communicating their sustainable value are precisely those that deal with the greatest restrictions in accessing these tools. In consequence, their competitiveness and growth potential become limited in markets that increasingly demand transparency and sustainability.

    The absence of legal requirements accounts for 18 % of the reasons for not implementing ir, highlighting a legal gap that circumscribes the widespread adoption of these practices. Tax incentives have been introduced in countries such as Brazil, Colombia, and Mexico since 2023, as well as more demanding regulatory frameworks such as the Climate Reporting Law in Chile and the expanded governance model requirements in Colombia since 2024. However, fragmentation persists in the Latin American regulatory landscape, causing uncertainty and inconsistencies in application (Sierra García et al., 2014). Business leaders often perceive ir as a cumbersome process that requires significant changes to corporate structure and operation. Such a complexity reinforces the need for a worldwide unified instrument that is easy to incorporate and free from all the barriers mentioned above (Stent & Dowler, 2015).

    The challenges faced by Latin American smes in implementing ir are mainly linked to the high information collection costs; the absence of mandatory regulatory frameworks; and the shortage of human resources, financing, and specialized training. This issue calls for strategic coordination between higher education institutions, governments, and the business sector (i.e., the triple helix). Together, they can develop alternatives that promote the building and strengthening of capacities in the field of ir for the preparation of sustainability reports that convey the reality of smes in the region.

    The main limitations of this study include the restricted scope of the sample, given that participation was concentrated on a small number of experts in Latin America. Similarly, the limited set of countries reduced the possibility of generalizing the results to the entire region. In addition, the evolution of ir adoption over time and its long-term impact on value creation could not be observed because of the cross-sectional nature of the study. In the qualitative component, the limited availability of experts and managers with in-depth knowledge of ir restricted the diversity of perspectives analyzed. Despite these constraints, this work provides a solid basis for future research that can delve deeper into the longitudinal, comparative, and sectoral analyses of ir in the Latin American context.

    Based on the results, new research avenues emerge in the sphere of ir from economic, social, and environmental perspectives in smes around the world. Particularly, emphasis should be placed on microenterprises, whose process in the adoption of these new instruments is the most complex due to the multiple difficulties previously identified. This area of research offers an unexplored field for yielding more detailed insights about the specific challenges and opportunities faced by microenterprises.

    CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

    The authors declare no financial, professional, or personal conflicts of interest that could have inappropriately influenced the results or interpretations presented in this study.

    AUTHOR CONTRIBUTIONS

    This article derives from the PhD research conducted by the lead author under the supervision of two dissertation advisors at the University of Zaragoza (Spain). The doctoral student was therefore in charge of the conceptualization, design, and development of the study, as well as the drafting of the manuscript. The final version of the paper was reviewed and approved by the advisors.

    REFERENCES

    ANNEXES

    Annex 1.
    Annexe 1.Table of input and output data for the DEA model
    Anexo 1. Tabla de datos de entrada y salida para el modelo DEA
    Economic inequality variables
    Fiscal mechanism variables
    Income level
    Country
    Year
    Domestic violence: Prevalence of intimate partner violence per 10,000 inhabitants
    Violence (homicides)
    Gini
    Pobrez
    Adult literacy rate (% of people aged 15 and above)
    Informality (waged workers employed, % of total employment)
    GDP growth (annual %)
    Revenue, excluding donations (% of GDP)
    Social contributions (% of revenue)
    Subsidies and other transfers (% of expense)
    High
    Spain
    2010
    1.1
    395
    35.2
    0.5
    99.71
    16.7
    0.2
    27.0
    42.0
    78.6
    2011
    0.8
    388
    35.7
    0.9
    99.73
    16.4
    -0.8
    26.4
    42.1
    78.7
    2012
    0.7
    345
    35.4
    0.6
    99.7
    17.3
    -3.0
    27.6
    42.6
    78.8
    2013
    0.7
    329
    36.2
    0.8
    99.56
    17.9
    -1.4
    26.4
    42.9
    78.6
    2014
    0.7
    298
    36.1
    0.5
    99.47
    17.6
    1.4
    27.2
    43.0
    78.5
    2015
    0.7
    294
    36.2
    0.6
    99.39
    17.3
    3.8
    26.3
    43.2
    78.6
    2016
    0.7
    294
    35.8
    0.7
    98.79
    16.9
    3.0
    26.9
    43.1
    79.4
    2017
    0.7
    325
    34.7
    0.5
    97.27
    16.5
    3.0
    27.1
    43.3
    79.5
    2018
    0.8
    275
    34.7
    0.6
    98.2
    16.0
    2.4
    27.9
    42.4
    79.3
    2019
    1.2
    262
    34.7
    0.6
    98.4
    15.7
    2.0
    28.0
    43.8
    80.1
    2020
    0.9
    261
    34.7
    0.6
    98.7
    15.6
    1.1
    28.1
    43.8
    80.1
    High
    United Kingdom
    2010
    5.9
    1.014
    0.1
    0.9
    98.0
    14.0
    1.9
    34.4
    21.7
    57.1
    2011
    5.8
    924
    0.3
    0.8
    98.1
    14.2
    1.5
    34.7
    21.4
    57.0
    2012
    6.0
    932
    0.1
    0.8
    98.4
    14.6
    1.5
    34.1
    21.2
    57.0
    2013
    7.4
    908
    0.1
    0.8
    99.7
    14.6
    2.1
    34.9
    20.8
    57.0
    2014
    5.6
    899
    0.1
    1.0
    99.9
    15.2
    2.6
    34.2
    20.9
    56.7
    2015
    7.4
    886
    0.1
    0.9
    99.9
    15.0
    2.4
    34.4
    21.2
    57.2
    2016
    5.9
    963
    0.1
    0.9
    99.7
    15.4
    1.9
    34.9
    21.4
    56.2
    2017
    6.2
    973
    0.2
    1.0
    99.5
    15.4
    1.9
    35.4
    21.5
    55.1
    2018
    6.9
    884
    0.2
    0.9
    99.3
    15.1
    1.3
    35.4
    21.6
    55.1
    2019
    7.2
    868
    0.2
    0.9
    99.4
    15.6
    1.5
    35.4
    22.6
    54.7
    2020
    6.6
    869
    0.2
    0.9
    99.6
    15.5
    0.4
    35.4
    22.5
    54.7
    High
    United States
    2010
    17.9
    16.912
    40.0
    12.6
    93.37
    7.04
    2.6
    16.5
    39.3
    62.7
    2011
    19.2
    16.746
    40.9
    13
    92.44
    6.82
    1.6
    16.7
    34.8
    62.1
    2012
    17.4
    17.233
    40.9
    14.9
    92.79
    6.75
    2.2
    16.8
    34.4
    62.4
    2013
    16.6
    16.616
    40.7
    15.8
    92.81
    6.59
    1.8
    18.9
    34.5
    63.9
    2014
    19.3
    16.277
    41.5
    15.8
    93.23
    6.45
    2.5
    18.9
    34.3
    64.5
    2015
    21.8
    18.364
    41.2
    15.5
    93.9
    6.44
    2.9
    19.1
    34.2
    65.8
    2016
    18.7
    20.069
    41.1
    15.1
    95.07
    6.39
    1.6
    18.7
    35.0
    65.9
    2017
    17.3
    20.383
    41.2
    14.6
    94.63
    6.25
    2.4
    19.5
    33.7
    65.7
    2018
    16.3
    18.902
    41.4
    14.1
    94.1
    6.28
    2.9
    17.5
    37.3
    65.0
    2019
    18.6
    18976
    41.4
    14.2
    94.2
    6.09
    2.2
    17.5
    37.5
    64.9
    2020
    17.5
    18975
    41.5
    14
    94.3
    6.10
    1.2
    17.5
    37.5
    64.8
    High
    Germany
    2010
    4.4
    124
    30.2
    0
    94.6
    11.6
    4.2
    28.0
    55.5
    77.9
    2011
    4.6
    125
    30.5
    0
    94.6
    11.7
    3.9
    28.3
    54.3
    80.5
    2012
    5.0
    124
    30.9
    0
    94.6
    11.6
    0.4
    28.6
    54.4
    80.6
    2013
    12.2
    117
    31.1
    0
    94.6
    11.2
    0.4
    28.5
    54.4
    81.7
    2014
    12.6
    114
    30.9
    0
    94.6
    11.0
    2.2
    28.5
    54.4
    82.2
    2015
    12.7
    114
    31.7
    0
    95.1
    10.8
    1.5
    28.5
    54.7
    82.9
    2016
    24.0
    111
    31.9
    0
    95.6
    10.4
    2.2
    28.4
    55.3
    82.9
    2017
    13.9
    113
    28.9
    0
    96.5
    10.2
    2.6
    28.6
    55.5
    82.1
    2018
    14.1
    113
    28.9
    0
    97.2
    9.9
    1.3
    29.0
    55.4
    82.9
    2019
    14.2
    112
    28.8
    0
    98.3
    9.6
    0.6
    29.4
    55.6
    83.0
    2020
    14.2
    112
    28.8
    0
    99.4
    9.6
    0.1
    29.4
    55.5
    83.1
    Upper-Middle
    Colombia
    2010
    17.2
    28.046
    54.6
    2.8
    93.4
    53.4
    4.5
    21.6
    12.5
    41.8
    2011
    18.1
    26.241
    53.5
    2.3
    93.6
    53.5
    6.9
    23.5
    18.0
    34.9
    2012
    15.7
    25.268
    52.6
    2.3
    93.4
    53.2
    3.9
    26.3
    20.1
    51.2
    2013
    14.9
    23.994
    52.6
    2.2
    93.8
    52.3
    5.1
    24.5
    13.0
    54.7
    2014
    22.9
    22.391
    52.6
    2
    94.2
    51.5
    4.5
    23.4
    15.9
    58.8
    2015
    18.4
    21.100
    51
    1.7
    94.2
    51.0
    3.0
    24.1
    16.4
    59.9
    2016
    24.9
    20.750
    50.6
    1.8
    94.7
    51.1
    2.1
    24.2
    18.2
    48.6
    2017
    18.4
    20.189
    49.7
    1.6
    94.9
    51.1
    1.4
    22.6
    7.3
    55.3
    2018
    19.5
    19.860
    50.4
    1.7
    95.1
    51.4
    2.5
    23.3
    11.2
    58.1
    2019
    15.1
    19.268
    51.3
    1.9
    95.1
    49.6
    3.3
    24.2
    11.5
    60.4
    2020
    17.2
    19.261
    51.3
    2
    95.0
    50.1
    -6.8
    24.2
    11.5
    60.3
    Upper-Middle
    Mexico
    2010
    14.2
    26.162
    47.2
    1.6
    93.1
    33.4
    5.1
    18.0
    11.5
    61.4
    2011
    16.7
    28.456
    47.5
    1.4
    93.5
    33.7
    3.7
    18.9
    10.9
    61.1
    2012
    14.3
    26.582
    48.7
    1.2
    94.2
    33.0
    3.6
    18.7
    11.1
    58.2
    2013
    12.7
    22.882
    48.6
    1.1
    94.0
    32.9
    1.4
    18.8
    11.5
    62.4
    2014
    14.1
    20.143
    48.7
    1.1
    94.6
    32.2
    2.8
    18.3
    11.8
    63.5
    2015
    12.5
    20.853
    47.3
    0.9
    94.5
    32.1
    3.3
    19.0
    11.6
    64.5
    2016
    11.9
    24.794
    46.3
    0.6
    94.9
    31.7
    2.6
    19.8
    10.9
    64.3
    2017
    10.7
    31.646
    46.8
    0.6
    95.0
    31.4
    2.1
    20.0
    10.7
    63.6
    2018
    9.5
    30.590
    45.4
    0.5
    95.4
    31.6
    2.2
    18.8
    11.5
    64.1
    2019
    9.8
    32.450
    45.4
    0.5
    95.4
    31.9
    -0.1
    18.6
    12.2
    65.4
    2020
    9.4
    32.440
    45.3
    0.5
    95.6
    32.0
    -8.2
    18.6
    12.1
    65.3
    Upper-Middle
    Brazil
    2010
    6.2
    60.959
    52.9
    1.8
    90.4
    32.1
    7.5
    29.0
    31.6
    57.9
    2011
    7.2
    60.598
    52.9
    1.9
    91.4
    31.5
    4.0
    29.1
    31.9
    57.1
    2012
    9.4
    65.011
    53.5
    1.4
    91.3
    29.9
    1.9
    29.6
    31.5
    59.2
    2013
    12.4
    63.943
    52.8
    1
    91.5
    30.1
    3.0
    28.7
    32.3
    59.1
    2014
    7.2
    64.564
    52.1
    0.9
    91.7
    30.0
    0.5
    27.4
    33.8
    58.8
    2015
    6.9
    64.859
    51.9
    1.1
    92.0
    31.3
    -3.5
    29.3
    31.6
    52.1
    2016
    6.8
    67.937
    53.3
    1.4
    92.8
    31.8
    -3.3
    29.6
    31.2
    56.9
    2017
    19.3
    68.886
    53.3
    1.6
    93.1
    32.3
    1.3
    27.9
    33.8
    59.4
    2018
    36.4
    68.129
    53.9
    1.6
    93.2
    32.8
    1.3
    29.1
    32.3
    59.0
    2019
    56.4
    68.779
    53.4
    1.7
    93.6
    33.1
    1.1
    29.7
    31.8
    61.7
    2020
    49.5
    68.770
    53.8
    1.7
    93.9
    33.1
    -0.8
    29.5
    31.8
    61.7
    Upper-Middle
    Russia
    2010
    15.1
    19.013
    39.5
    0
    94.1
    6.8
    4.5
    26.1
    20.3
    60.5
    2011
    14.3
    17.650
    39.7
    0
    95.4
    7.0
    4.3
    29.1
    19.5
    59.8
    2012
    12.6
    16.275
    40.7
    0
    96.3
    6.9
    4.0
    27.2
    21.0
    59.4
    2013
    14.6
    16.048
    40.9
    0
    96.2
    7.2
    1.8
    26.5
    25.2
    61.2
    2014
    17.9
    16.519
    39.9
    0
    94.4
    7.2
    0.7
    27.2
    26.1
    66.3
    2015
    16.3
    16.645
    37.7
    0
    95.7
    7.2
    -2.0
    24.5
    21.4
    68.9
    2016
    19.1
    15.868
    36.8
    0
    96.7
    7.5
    0.2
    24.3
    26.5
    71.2
    2017
    24.9
    13.316
    37.2
    0
    95.1
    6.6
    1.8
    24.5
    22.9
    70.6
    2018
    22.4
    12.296
    37.5
    0
    96.4
    6.8
    2.5
    27.3
    21.9
    68.8
    2019
    21.4
    11.450
    37.4
    0
    98.6
    8.2
    1.3
    27.4
    22.4
    69.0
    2020
    18.6
    11.452
    37.5
    0
    99.4
    8.14.
    0.7
    27.1
    22.3
    68.9
    Lower-Middle
    Nigeria
    2010
    65.1
    17.110
    36.1
    13.4
    64.1
    82.6
    8.0
    16.4
    7.2
    0.0
    2011
    66.5
    17.229
    36.6
    11.9
    63.4
    81.1
    5.3
    19.0
    7.2
    0.0
    2012
    64.3
    17.287
    38.7
    12.5
    62.5
    81.6
    4.2
    20.9
    7.0
    0.0
    2013
    69.4
    17.573
    39.4
    12.7
    64.1
    81.9
    6.7
    24.3
    7.5
    0.0
    2014
    68.0
    17.868
    38.4
    12.5
    63.7
    81.6
    6.3
    27.6
    8.2
    0.0
    2015
    64.1
    18.026
    36.7
    11.6
    63.6
    82.3
    2.7
    24.4
    8.0
    0.0
    2016
    68.2
    18.210
    36.4
    13.4
    62.1
    82.6
    -1.6
    21.6
    8.0
    0.0
    2017
    72.1
    18.250
    36.4
    12.6
    62.5
    81.5
    0.8
    24.0
    4.2
    0.0
    2018
    74.3
    18.305
    35.1
    12.5
    62.4
    80.5
    1.9
    23.3
    4.3
    0.0
    2019
    78.3
    18.407
    35.4
    12.4
    62.9
    79.9
    2.2
    28.9
    4.8
    0.0
    2020
    79.4
    18.408
    35.2
    12.6
    62.0
    79.9
    1.5
    28.9
    4.9
    0.0
    Lower-Middle
    Nicaragua
    2010
    7.5
    858
    47.3
    1.4
    81.3
    48.8
    4.4
    14.7
    0.0
    37.1
    2011
    6.9
    821
    47.5
    1.2
    81.4
    48.1
    6.3
    15.8
    0.0
    34.3
    2012
    9.2
    767
    47.4
    1.3
    80.3
    47.3
    6.5
    16.4
    0.0
    33.7
    2013
    6.1
    715
    48.6
    1.1
    80.7
    46.5
    4.9
    16.2
    0.0
    34.1
    2014
    7.5
    667
    46.2
    0.8
    81.2
    45.7
    4.8
    16.4
    0.0
    32.3
    2015
    4.4
    637
    46.1
    0.9
    81.3
    44.8
    4.8
    16.7
    0.0
    34.4
    2016
    7.1
    607
    46.2
    0.8
    81.2
    43.9
    4.6
    17.4
    0.0
    31.8
    2017
    11.9
    614
    46.8
    0.9
    82.6
    43.0
    4.6
    17.8
    0.0
    31.9
    2018
    12.5
    631
    46.2
    1.0
    82.4
    42.8
    -3.9
    16.9
    0.0
    32.0
    2019
    14.9
    619
    46.2
    0.9
    82.5
    42.7
    -3.9
    19.1
    0.0
    28.9
    2020
    16.2
    620
    46.2
    0.8
    82.1
    42.6
    -5.7
    19.2
    0.0
    28.9
    Lower-Middle
    El Salvador
    2010
    5.0
    4.429
    43.5
    1.5
    84.5
    41.8
    2.1
    22.0
    11.6
    22.5
    2011
    7.6
    4.376
    42.3
    1.1
    85.5
    41.7
    3.8
    23.2
    10.2
    24.9
    2012
    5.6
    3.884
    41.8
    1.0
    85.4
    41.8
    2.8
    22.7
    11.2
    24.4
    2013
    9.0
    3.981
    43.4
    0.8
    86.8
    41.9
    2.2
    21.1
    11.0
    14.7
    2014
    7.0
    4.657
    41.6
    0.7
    87.0
    39.6
    1.7
    20.6
    11.3
    27.7
    2015
    6.7
    5.537
    40.6
    0.4
    88.0
    40.4
    2.4
    20.8
    11.6
    28.5
    2016
    7.0
    5.483
    40.0
    0.5
    88.1
    40.0
    2.5
    23.7
    11.2
    21.6
    2017
    10.8
    5.109
    38.0
    0.4
    88.5
    40.2
    2.2
    25.1
    10.6
    19.4
    2018
    14.6
    5.345
    38.6
    0.3
    89.0
    38.8
    2.4
    24.9
    9.7
    17.7
    2019
    15.2
    5.485
    38.8
    0.2
    89.1
    39.1
    2.4
    24.0
    11.2
    19.7
    2020
    14.1
    5.487
    38.8
    0.2
    89.1
    39.1
    1.1
    24.0
    11.2
    19.7
    Lower-Middle
    India
    2010
    21.6
    53.464
    36.4
    4.8
    69.4
    83.3
    8.5
    13.2
    0.3
    37.0
    2011
    23.2
    53.957
    35.7
    4.6
    69.3
    82.0
    5.2
    11.5
    0.1
    37.3
    2012
    22.0
    53.904
    35.4
    4.7
    69.4
    80.7
    5.5
    12.6
    0.2
    38.8
    2013
    22.5
    53.470
    35.9
    4.1
    70.1
    80.1
    6.4
    12.6
    0.2
    40.5
    2014
    17.6
    53.309
    35.8
    3.9
    70.6
    79.5
    7.4
    11.6
    0.1
    37.7
    2015
    20.0
    52.314
    35.1
    4.7
    71.5
    78.8
    8.0
    12.4
    0.1
    40.7
    2016
    23.0
    51.532
    35.8
    4.2
    72.9
    78.1
    8.3
    12.9
    0.1
    42.7
    2017
    22.3
    52.057
    35.7
    4.6
    73.4
    77.3
    7.0
    12.7
    0.1
    44.1
    2018
    23.1
    51.979
    35.6
    4.1
    74.6
    76.5
    6.1
    13.1
    0.1
    44.6
    2019
    22.9
    51.767
    35.7
    4.8
    74.4
    75.8
    4.2
    13.1
    0.1
    44.5
    2020
    23.5
    51.766
    35.7
    4.9
    74.2
    75.5
    2.1
    13.1
    0.1
    44.5
    Low
    Afganistan
    2010
    49
    2.638
    27.4
    61.2
    31.1
    88.6
    14.4
    11.1
    0.3
    1.8
    2011
    29
    2.666
    27.3
    61.4
    31.4
    87.9
    0.4
    11.5
    0.3
    2.1
    2012
    52
    2.702
    27.8
    61.5
    31.4
    86.6
    12.8
    10.2
    0.5
    2.7
    2013
    46
    2.783
    27.8
    61.7
    31.6
    85.7
    5.6
    9.4
    0.5
    2.9
    2014
    41
    2.853
    28.6
    61.1
    31.9
    84.9
    2.7
    8.6
    0.6
    3.9
    2015
    49
    3.130
    28.4
    61.7
    32.4
    84.2
    1.5
    10.1
    0.6
    4.5
    2016
    49
    3.191
    28.6
    61.8
    35.9
    83.5
    2.3
    12.7
    0.6
    8.4
    2017
    45
    3.031
    28.1
    61.3
    38.4
    82.5
    2.6
    13.0
    0.6
    10.5
    2018
    51
    3.168
    27.8
    61
    43.1
    82.3
    1.2
    12.9
    0.6
    10.4
    2019
    55
    3.217
    28.3
    61.3
    43.5
    82.2
    3.9
    13.1
    0.6
    10.5
    2020
    57
    3.219
    28.6
    61.6
    43.7
    82.3
    1.3
    13.0
    0.6
    10.5
    Low
    Haiti
    2010
    14.9
    2.120
    42.6
    7.9
    60.1
    75.3
    -3.8
    10.1
    0.0
    0.0
    2011
    13.9
    2.118
    46.1
    8.1
    60.7
    74.7
    6.2
    10.5
    0.0
    0.0
    2012
    19.3
    2.142
    41.1
    8.0
    60.4
    74.6
    0.6
    9.2
    0.0
    0.0
    2013
    17.8
    2.173
    42.6
    8.1
    61.4
    74.3
    3.1
    9.4
    0.0
    0.0
    2014
    13.2
    2.200
    42.7
    8.3
    61.9
    74.0
    3.4
    8.3
    0.0
    0.0
    2015
    28.0
    2.221
    43.1
    8.4
    61.4
    73.8
    1.6
    9.1
    0.0
    0.0
    2016
    5.6
    2.244
    43.5
    7.9
    61.5
    73.8
    1.7
    10.7
    0.0
    0.0
    2017
    8.5
    2.265
    43.6
    8.1
    61.7
    73.7
    2.3
    11.0
    0.0
    0.0
    2018
    15.3
    2.305
    43.7
    8.1
    61.7
    73.5
    1.7
    11.9
    0.0
    0.0
    2019
    17.8
    2.330
    43.6
    8.0
    61.7
    73.5
    -1.7
    11.1
    0.0
    0.0
    2020
    16.7
    2.331
    42.1
    8.2
    61.8
    73.5
    -5.7
    11.0
    0.0
    0.0
    Low
    Uganda
    2010
    25.5
    3.808
    40.9
    37.9
    73.2
    81.3
    5.6
    11.3
    0.0
    30.4
    2011
    25.0
    4.186
    40.8
    38.1
    73.1
    80.1
    9.4
    11.2
    0.0
    30.8
    2012
    33.4
    4.435
    41.1
    40.3
    70.3
    79.5
    3.8
    11.5
    0.0
    30.4
    2013
    30.2
    4.605
    41
    40.2
    70.4
    79.2
    3.6
    11.1
    0.0
    29.4
    2014
    29.7
    4.885
    41.1
    40.9
    70.5
    79.0
    5.1
    11.4
    0.0
    29.7
    2015
    29.9
    5.041
    41.6
    41.2
    70.6
    78.6
    5.2
    11.6
    0.0
    30.6
    2016
    31.0
    5.205
    41.4
    40.6
    71.9
    78.3
    4.8
    12.0
    0.0
    27.9
    2017
    30.2
    5.405
    42.8
    40.7
    70.8
    78.3
    3.8
    12.4
    0.0
    28.7
    2018
    36.2
    5.867
    42.9
    40.1
    72.6
    77.8
    6.2
    12.5
    0.0
    18.3
    2019
    38.2
    6.175
    42.8
    41.3
    76.5
    77.3
    6.8
    13.2
    0.0
    28.9
    2020
    34.1
    6.174
    42.8
    41.6
    76.2
    77.3
    4.1
    13.2
    0.0
    28.6
    Low
    Madagascar
    2010
    24.3
    1.718
    42.4
    71.7
    70.6
    90.7
    0.6
    10.6
    6.6
    26.5
    2011
    21.2
    1.727
    42.3
    70.7
    70.4
    89.9
    1.6
    9.7
    7.1
    30.7
    2012
    26.1
    1.700
    42.6
    70.7
    71.6
    89.0
    3.0
    9.2
    3.1
    32.7
    2013
    23.4
    1.715
    42.6
    70.2
    72.4
    89.2
    2.3
    9.5
    4.3
    36.5
    2014
    21.9
    1.744
    42.8
    70.6
    72.1
    89.2
    3.3
    9.3
    3.9
    36.2
    2015
    20.1
    1.731
    42.7
    70.1
    73.6
    89.4
    3.1
    9.8
    3.8
    34.4
    2016
    17.5
    1.739
    42.9
    70.5
    73.8
    89.2
    4.0
    10.1
    2.8
    32.3
    2017
    16.8
    1.761
    42.5
    70.7
    73.4
    89.0
    3.9
    10.9
    3.0
    40.2
    2018
    17.5
    1.761
    42.4
    70.7
    74.2
    88.2
    4.6
    11.4
    5.0
    30.5
    2019
    18.4
    1.749
    42.1
    70.7
    74.8
    87.8
    4.9
    11.6
    4.1
    37.1
    2020
    14.8
    1748
    42.8
    70.7
    74.8
    87.1
    1.7
    11.6
    4.2
    37.1
    Fuente: Authors’ own work based on definitions from the International Labour Organization (ILO), the World Bank Group (WBG), and the World Health Organization (WHO).
    Annex 2. RStudio code for the development of the Data Envelopment Analysis

    > View(Datos1)

    > summary(Datos1)

    > describe(Datos1)

    > describe(Datos1$VioFam)

    > describe(Datos1$Homic)|

    > describe(Datos1$Gini)

    > describe(Datos1$Pobrez)

    > describe(Datos1$Alfabet)

    > describe(Datos1$PIB)

    > describe(Datos1$Recaud)

    > describe(Datos1$Contribuc)

    > describe(Datos1$Transf)

    > class(Datos1)

    > str(Datos1)

    > x<- with(Datos1. cbind(VioFam. Homic. Gini. Pobrez. Alfabet))

    > y<-matrix(Datos1$Transf)

    > y<-matrix(Datos1$PIB)

    > y<-matrix(Datos1$Informal)

    > y<-matrix(Datos1$Recaud)

    > y<-matrix(Datos1$Contribuc)

    > bcc<- dea(x.y. RTS = "vrs". ORIENTATION = "in")

    > bcc

    > shapiro.test(bcc$eff)

    > eff(bcc)

    > data.frame(bcc$eff)

    > summary(bcc)

    > sl<- slack(x.y. bcc)

    > data.frame(eff(bcc). eff(sl).sl$slack. sl$sx. sl$sy. lambda(sl))

    > dea.plot(x.y. RTS = "vrs". ORIENTATION = "in-out")

    > bccb<- dea.boot(x.y. NREP = 3000. RTS = "vrs". ORIENTATION = "in". alpha = 0.05)

    > bccb

    > superbcc <- sdea(x.y. RTS = "vrs". ORIENTATION = "in")

    > superbcc

    > print(peers(superbcc. NAMES = TRUE). quote = FALSE)

    > excess(bcc. x)

    > ccr<- dea(x.y. RTS = "crs". ORIENTATION = "in")

    > ccr

    > shapiro.test(ccr$eff)

    > dea.plot(x.y. RTS = "crs". ORIENTATION = "in-out". add = TRUE. lty="dashed")

    > superccr <- sdea(x.y. RTS = "crs". ORIENTATION = "in")

    > superccr

    > rint(peers(superccr.NAMES = TRUE).quote = FALSE)