News Agendas, Circularity of Knowledge, and Environmental Risks and Disasters: A Transdisciplinary Approach

DOI 10.22430/21457778.1273


 

EDITORIAL

The media is constantly proposing agendas and frameworks of interpretation to its audiences, while reflecting their socio-cultural context. This can be seen in both traditional media and emerging communication environments. Increasingly, the media are trying to give their users more visibility, especially through their digital footprints, and even inviting co-production and co-creation (Scolari, 2009; Bonilla et al, 2012). In other words, the relationship between the media and the public has always been complex, and this is increasingly so. State and international regulations play an essential role there, although they often lag behind the developments in this relationship (Castells, 2009). It is therefore clear that there is an important accountability on the part of the media in the construction of the agendas, an accountability that also concerns the authorities that regulate them and the citizens that use them. One of the most important research macro-objects in the field of science, technology, and society (STS) studies has to do precisely with the way knowledge circulates among the media, particularly the news media, authorities, scientists and experts, interest groups, and citizens in general. In this sense, the subfield of public communication of science and technology (PCST) has much to contribute and has permanent challenges towards and from STS studies. This is a subfield that also feeds theoretically and methodologically into the field of communication studies (CE), which also has much to learn from STS perspectives.

However, Latin America, and especially Colombia, have much to do in establishing connections between the fields of STS and CE studies, including the developments of PCST (Cortassa, 2014; Massarani et al, 2017; Hermelin, 2018). Such an obligation reaches out to a wider international audience (Bucchi & Trench, 2014; Kreimer, 2015).  Briefly, for STS studies it is essential to deal with the links between the circulation of knowledge and the agendas of the different actors, especially those of the media, for which it is imperative to open analytical perspectives in dialogue with other fields. Latin America has made significant theoretical progress in STS studies, as attested to by a good number of articles published in the journal Trilogía since 2009; however, there are still tasks to be carried out in their corresponding field of practice, especially with regard to the construction of news reports. Significant gaps exist in the treatment of science and technology issues in the most widely consumed Latin American media; gaps that are particularly noticeable in terms of STS debates permeating media agendas, as shown by Massarani and Ramalho (2012).  Individual and collective risk issues, such as those related to the environment, point to obstacles and challenges in this direction. For example, on an issue of such a high impact as climate change, there are studies indicating that there is little contrast between the sources, and that there are deficiencies in the multi-stakeholder debates, as derived from Arcila et al., (2015) for the Spanish-speaking media context, and from Lema et al., (2017) in the Colombian media context.

From now on we will focus on some challenges and opportunities that are opening up in Colombia for the relationship between STS studies (as a theoretical and practical field), environmental issues, especially those related to disaster risks, and media agendas.  It should be added that some elements of this discussion can be easily transferred to other fields. Firstly, one must say that in recent decades Colombia, consistent with the Latin American and international context, has made progress in the field of disaster risk management (DRM). This is so after having undergone an overwhelming number of large-scale disasters with serious consequences, but also summing up small-scale disasters, causing a huge number of victims and damage each year (Campos et al., 2012). A large part of the Colombian population is exposed to high or medium level threats from earthquakes, floods and mass movements, among others (UNGRD, 2014). One has to say, however, that despite its major shortcomings, news coverage has had an impact on DRM developments. All this has given rise to specific regulations, such as the Act 1523 of 2012 (Congreso de la República, 2012), which provides for strict management of disaster risk at the national, regional and local levels. Disaster risk has been emphasized in DRM policies as a social construct, as something inherent in the development of relations between communities and the territory. A call for a paradigm shift in which disasters, and even disaster risks, are conceived as inevitable (García Acosta, 2005; Lavell, 2006; Gellert-de-Pinto, 2012). On the other hand, Cortés Fonnegra (2018) suggests that there are many possibilities for the DRM field to draw on STS perspectives and vice versa, particularly in Colombia. Hence, and given that DRM policies are interrelated with science policies which, in turn, are a type of public policy that responds to the interests of a variety of actors in the national and international science and technology systems (Escobar Ortiz, 2018), approaches from STS studies are unavoidable for a country like Colombia.

Secondly, and bearing in mind the above, there is the need to cross-reference STS and CE studies, going through the PCST subfield, and the DRM field within the Colombian (and even the Latin American and international) academic context. In Colombia, the circulation of knowledge, in which the media and their agendas intervene, in relation to environmental problems, disasters and their risks, points to the relevance of these inter-campus approaches. Studies into the nature of this circulation encourage the implementation of multiple theoretical and methodological approaches. Let us take a look at what such studies reveal. Daza-Caicedo and Lozano-Borda (2014) show how Colombian citizens give prominence to the media to get closer to problems and knowledge of a techno-scientific nature. Daza-Caicedo (2009) finds the same trend, which is even more pronounced with regard to environmental issues; when it comes to risks of this nature, people consider themselves quite interested and even appropriated or aware of such knowledge. Meanwhile, Barrios et al. (2017) and Obregón et al., (2009) show how difficult it is for high-impact Latin American media, including Colombian media, to report on the paradigm shift in DRM. Again, there is relatively little involvement of scientists and experts as a source for these issues.  Thus, with regard to the notion of environmental risks and disasters, there are signs that the agendas demanded by citizens and the agendas proposed by the Colombian news media are overlapping, in addition to some difficulties in making techno-scientific knowledge standard in both agendas.

However, within the framework of the circularity of knowledge between actors, the purpose of this discussion is not to give a complete dominance to techno-scientific knowledge as a means of strengthening DRM.  Circularity calls precisely upon the importance of the cultural repertoires of the many actors, and their multiple rationalities, beyond the rationality portrayed as a single and valid reason. Following Marquez (2008), the multiple rationalities required to understand the complex social and media relations with risk management in the Colombian context.  In this sense, we should think more in terms of PCST democratic models than deficit models (Lozano, 2005; Rivera Berrío, 2010; Pérez-Bustos & Lozano-Borda, 2011), that is, horizontal rather than vertical models, between the supposedly enlightened and the supposedly lay. (As derived from Lundgren and MacMakin (2009), the most prescriptive models in the subfield of risk communication are very close to deficit models; in contrast, their more dialogical models are very close to democratic ones). Something that, according to Rancière (2010), implies understanding the knowledge gradients between different actors as conditions of possibility for the activity and the co-construction of knowledge. The news media clearly have a fundamental role to play: they are not just any actor in circularity, since they are the communicating vessels, par excellence, between multiple actors, and they are called upon to act as a counterweight to other powers.  In both ways they contribute to the social fabric linked to the conception of environmental risks (De Cheveigné, 2000), specifically to DRM. The media are called upon to use democratic models, with multiple voices, that favor debate in order to empower different social segments, instead of making simple translations of the positions and languages of epistemic and state authorities. But the media, in turn, must ponder when it becomes inexorable to use deficit models in dealing with a crisis situation, as with an impending disaster.  Of course, examining these media functions is one of the tasks for what we have called here the inter-campus approach.

To address issues such as those we have discussed, it is necessary to understand the socio-cultural, historical and political contexts in which different actors' agendas, including those of the news media, are built and intertwine. In our case, it is necessary to emphasize particularities of Colombia's recent past and present. One essential peculiarity that has been reflected in news agendas in recent years has to do with the armed conflict.  After the negotiations between the paramilitary groups and the national government from 2002 to 2010, and after the negotiations and the signing of the peace agreements between the FARC guerrillas and the national government from 2010 to 2018, the news priorities have changed significantly. Government and other independent figures have shown a substantial decrease in homicides, massacres and kidnappings. In fact, it is reported that 2017 saw the lowest homicide rate in 42 years (El Espectador, 2018). Moreover, the armed conflict has not only taken over the agendas of the news media, the authorities, and the citizenry: it has prevailed in much of the media analysis of academics in Colombia (Tamayo & Bonilla, 2014). These variations in violence indicators are reflected in the fact that other issues have become or may become important. In fact, this is an opportunity for the different actors to give more space to other issues, especially those that we are dealing with here: environmental disasters and their risks. This is an opportunity for the news media, state authorities, academia and the public. For example, a relevant challenge is the possibility of the news media to focus its attention not only on environmental disasters, but also on the risks, as a consequence of the decrease in violent acts linked to the armed conflict. (Could this give them less excuses to cover the latter?).  Following Beck (2006), this is a challenge that also concerns the other actors mentioned, one that has to do with our transition to a risk society, with its great benefits, without losing sight of its adversities.

The possibilities of paving the way to strengthen the field of DRM in Colombia are thus apparent, in dialogue with that of STS studies and that of CE studies, in all three cases as study fields, but also with their corresponding practice fields.  In general terms, some points have been made here about the need to implement multi-field approaches in specific contexts. We believe this perspective to be useful in Colombia and elsewhere, and may serve as a kind of suggestion to think about the various works published in this issue of Trilogía, a journal that, in our opinion, strongly advocates transdisciplinarity.

References

  • arrow_upward Arcila-Calderón, C., Mercado, M. T., Piñuel-Raigada, J. L., & Suárez-Sucre, E. (2015). Media coverage of climate change in Spanish-Speaking online media. Convergencia, 22(68), 71–95.
  • arrow_upward Barrios, M. M., Arroyave, J., & Vega, L. (2017). El cambio de paradigma en la cobertura informativa de la gestión de riesgo de desastres: retos y oportunidades. Chasqui. Revista Latinoamericana de Comunicación (136), 129–144.
  • arrow_upward Beck, U. (2006). La sociedad del riesgo. Hacia una nueva modernidad. Barcelona: Paidós.
  • arrow_upward Bonilla, J. I., Cataño, M., Rincón, O., & Zuluaga, J. (2012). De las audiencias contemplativas a los productores conectados. Cali, Medellín, and Bogotá: Pontificia Universidad Javeriana, Universidad EAFIT, and Universidad de los Andes.
  • arrow_upward Bucchi, M., & Trench, B. (Eds.). (2014). Handbook of Public Communication of Science and Technology. London: Routledge.
  • arrow_upward Campos, A., Holm-Nielsen, N., Díaz C., Rubiano, D. M., Costa. C. R., Ramírez, F., & Dickson, E. (Eds.). (2012). Análisis de la gestión del riesgo de desastres en Colombia: un aporte para la construcción de políticas públicas. Bogotá: The World Bank, GFDRR.
  • arrow_upward Castells, M. (2009). Comunicación y poder. Madrid: Alianza Editorial.
  • arrow_upward Congreso de la República. (2012). Ley 1523 de 2012. Por la cual se adopta la política nacional de gestión del riesgo de desastres y se establece el Sistema Nacional de Gestión del Riesgo de Desastres y se dictan otras disposiciones. Bogotá: Congreso de la República de Colombia. Retrieved from http://www.secretariasenado.gov.co/senado/basedoc/ley_1523_2012.html">
  • arrow_upward Cortassa, C. (2014). Ciencia y audiencias: aportes para consolidar una agenda de investigación. Diálogos de la Comunicación-FELAFACS, 88, 1–17.
  • arrow_upward Cortés Fonnegra, L. M. (2018). Reflexión sobre la gestión de riesgos de desastres bajo la perspectiva CTS. Trilogía Ciencia Tecnología Sociedad, 10(19), 7–10.
  • arrow_upward Daza-Caicedo, S. (Ed.). (2009). Percepciones sobre la ciencia y la tecnología en Bogotá. Bogotá: Observatorio Colombiano de Ciencia y Tecnología.
  • arrow_upward Daza-Caicedo, S., & Lozano-borda, M. (Eds.). (2014). Percepciones de las Ciencias y las Tecnologías en Colombia. Resultados de la III Encuesta Nacional de Percepción Pública de la Ciencia y la Tecnología. Bogotá: Observatorio Colombiano de Ciencia y Tecnología.
  • arrow_upward De Cheveigné, S. (2000). L’environnement dans les journaux télévisés. Médiateurs et visions du monde. Paris: CNRS éditions.
  • arrow_upward El Espectador. (January 21, 2018). Homicidios en Colombia: la tasa más baja en los últimos 42 años se dio en 2017. El Espectador. Retrieved from https://www.elespectador.com/noticias/judicial/homicidios-en-colombia-la-tasa-mas-baja-en-los-ultimos-42-anos-se-dio-en-2017-articulo-734526
  • arrow_upward Escobar Ortiz, J. M. (2018). El diseño de la política científica en América Latina: organismos internacionales, gobiernos nacionales y comunidades científicas. Trilogía Ciencia Tecnología y Sociedad, 10(18), 7–11.
  • arrow_upward García Acosta, V. (2005). El riesgo como construcción social y la construcción social de riesgos. Desacatos. Revista de Antropología Social, 19, 11–24.
  • arrow_upward Gellert-de-Pinto, G. I. (2012). El cambio de paradigma: de la atención de desastres a la gestión del riesgo. Boletín Científico Sapiens Research, 2(1), 13–17.
  • arrow_upward Hermelin, D. (2018). Comunicación de la ciencia. Un aprendizaje desde y con las ciencias sociales y humanas. InMediaciones de la Comunicación, 13(2), 51–70.
  • arrow_upward Kreimer, P. (2015). Public understanding of science and social studies of science: convergence or parallel paths? In B. Schiele, J. L. Marec, & P. Baranger (Eds.), Science Communication Today (pp. 1-16). Nancy: PUN.
  • arrow_upward Lavell, A. M. (2006). Apuntes para una reflexión institucional en países de la Subregión andina sobre el enfoque de la Gestión del Riesgo. Lima: PREDECAN. Retrieved from http://www.comunidadandina.org/predecan/doc/r1/docAllan2.pdf
  • arrow_upward Lema-Velez, L. F., Hermelin, D., Fontecha, M. M., & Urrego, D. H. (2017). Climate Change Communication in Colombia. Climate change communication. Climate science. Oxford Research Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://climatescience.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228620.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228620-e-598
  • arrow_upward Lozano, M. (2005). Programas y experiencias en popularización de la ciencia y la tecnología. Panorámica desde los países del Convenio Andrés Bello. Bogotá: Convenio Andrés Bello.
  • arrow_upward Lundgren, R. E., & MacMakin, A. H. (2009). Risk communication. A handbook for communicating environmental, safety, and health risks. New Jersey: IEE press and John Wiley & Sons.
  • arrow_upward Márquez, J. (2008). Ciencia, riesgos colectivos y prensa escrita. El caso del sida en Colombia. Medellín: Universidad Nacional de Colombia.
  • arrow_upward Massarani, L. et al. (2017). Aproximaciones a la investigación en divulgación de la ciencia en América Latina a partir de sus artículos académicos. Rio de Janeiro, Brazil: Fiocruz.
  • arrow_upward Massarani, L., & Ramalho, M. (Eds.). (2012). Monitoramento e capacitação em jornalismo científico - a experiência de uma rede ibero-americana. Rio de Janeiro and Quito: Museu da Vida/Casa de Oswaldo Cruz and Ciespal.
  • arrow_upward Obregón, R., Arroyave, J., & Barrios, M. M. (2009). Cubrimiento periodístico de la gestión del riesgo en la Subregión Andina: discursos periodísticos y perspectivas desde la comunicación para el cambio social. Lima: PREDECAN, Comunidad Andina de Naciones.
  • arrow_upward Pérez-Bustos, T., & Lozano-Borda, M. (Eds.). (2011). Ciencia, tecnología y democracia. Reflexiones en torno a la apropiación social del conocimiento. Medellín: Colciencias and Universidad EAFIT.
  • arrow_upward Rancière, J. (2010). El espectador emancipado. Buenos Aires: Manantial.
  • arrow_upward Rivera Berrío, J. G. (2010). La comunicación del riesgo: hacia un modelo efectivo y situacional. Medellín: Fondo Editorial ITM.
  • arrow_upward Scolari, C. (2009). Alrededor de la(s) convergencia(s). Conversaciones teóricas, divergencias conceptuales y transformaciones en el ecosistema de medios. Signo y Pensamiento, 28(54), 44–55.
  • arrow_upward Tamayo, C., & Bonilla, J. I. (2014). El deber de la memoria. La agenda investigativa sobre la cobertura informativa del conflicto armado en Colombia, 2002-2012. Palabra Clave, 17(1), 13–45.
  • arrow_upward Unidad Nacional para la Gestión del Riesgo de Desastres (UNGRD). (2014). Documento de priorización de líneas estratégicas y zonas de intervención en gestión del riesgo de desastres en Colombia (2014-2018). Bogotá: UNGRD.