From the Fourth Urban Revolution to the Fourth Industrial Revolution: Challenges Around Environmental Air Quality Issues for Medellín and the Valle de Aburrá

 

DOI 10.22430/21457778.1598
EDITORIAL

After the creation of a center to enable its development in 2019, the idea of a fourth industrial revolution has become quite common in Medellín and the Valle de Aburrá. However, beyond the city marketing strategy upon which the World Economic Forum (WEF) based its decision to choose the capital to establish the center, some questions arise. For instance, if we are dealing with the fourth, do we know something about the first, second or third revolutions? Do we know what is an industrial revolution? And most importantly, what are the challenges for Medellín in the unfolding of this revolution? We will now try to briefly answer these questions, focusing on the close historical and geographical relationship between the industrial and urban revolutions.

From approximately the 15th century, when the so-called modernity began in the West, until the 19th century when society would consolidate its organization around capitalism, there developed, among other social processes, the urbanization of the territory and its later industrialization as a production system to satisfy people's needs and desires through goods and services. In their evolution, both processes have become more complex. Thus we are witnessing what some authors have termed the fourth urban revolution, along with what others have referred to as the fourth industrial revolution. But, what about the former ones?

According to Soja (2008), at the beginning of the Neolithic period -approximately since the 7th century B.C.- groups of nomadic hunter-gatherers began a process of sedentism based on the coinciding development of two dynamics starting the relationship between two different but complementary spaces, the countryside and the city: both the first urban and the first agricultural revolution. These events occurred in what is known as Mesopotamia, between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers in the Middle East. Later, during Antiquity - approximately since the 4th century B.C.- with the dominance of sedentary groups over territory and populations and along with the advent of the writing, the State was born, as well as the first city-states, such as Uruk and Ur, in what is now Iraq, and then others such as Athens and Sparta in Greece, in a process that is known as the second urban revolution.

More than two millennia later, in Modern times, the third urban revolution takes place, in parallel with the 18th century first Industrial Revolution in England. So the capitalist system of production, which consolidated in the 19th century, is determined by a simultaneous industrialization and urbanization process (Marx & Engels, 2007). This first revolution took a little less than a hundred years, from the second half of the 18th century to the first half of the 19th century and is usually referred to as the Industrial Revolution. But what is an industrial revolution? In short, it is a process of restructuring the production system as a consequence of social and spatial change in which, from that moment on, industry participates.

The Industrial Revolution got its momentum with the invention of the steam engine, which runs on fossil energy produced by the combustion of coal, replacing the until then widespread animal and hydraulic forms of energy. This marks the beginning of nothing less than the mechanical production in agriculture and industry, so that the first businesses are in rural areas, close to water and energy sources such as coal mines. Later, still during the 19th century, the implementation of the steam engine in trains and ships also allowed the transformation of the space-time relationship, making it possible to bring energy sources to the city.

A double process of industrialization and urbanization is then developed, arising from the migration of peasant workers who are becoming paid workers. That is, the process of social production that until then had been found mainly in the countryside is now centered in urban areas. This process of reorganization of the country-city relationship led to the emergence of the second industrial revolution, between the last half of the 19th century and the first of the 20th. This revolution was brought about by the diversification of fossil energy sources, in addition to coal, such as oil and natural gas, along with the emergence of electric power and the development of its transmission.

In this way, businesses are definitively established in cities thanks to the large population that is settling there and that enables the implementation of the assembly line industry, a production model explored by Frederick Winslow Taylor in the United States, in what is known as Taylorism. This model would later inspire the rise of Fordism, the large-scale production devised by Henry Ford, who originally implemented it in the car industry, the most iconic of this period, as it became a reference for other industries also starting mass production.

Similarly, during the first decades of the 20th century there was a great growth of industrial cities, such as Manchester and Chicago. Simultaneously in Latin America, after the First World War (1914-1918), import substitution industrialization (ISI) policies, inspired by Fordism, were set with the aim of replacing, through industrial production, the fall in imports from industrialized countries that were at war, which contributed to the urbanization process of the region during that century.

But it is not until the second half of the 20th century that the third industrial revolution takes place, initially inspired by development of the Japanese car industry model, Toyotaism, which makes the assembly line more flexible, through the invention of the computer that allowed production automation. Likewise, at the end of the century, both the personal computer and the Internet drove the expansion of new information and communication technologies in the context of globalization. These changes in society, which is already distinctly capitalist, also shape the reflection on the crisis of modern rationality.

In this time of the crisis of reason, which peaked in the transition from the 1960s to the 1970s, environmental and urban problems, among others, were recognized. It is worth remembering, for example, that in 1972 the First United Nations Conference on the Human Environment was held in Stockholm, Sweden, and that in 1976 the First United Nations Conference on Urban Settlements, known as Habitat I, was held in Vancouver, Canada.

In this context, Soja (2008) proposes the emergence of the fourth urban revolution, a trend that continues today at the beginning of the 21st century. This is what Lefebvre (1972) describes as a hypothesis: The process of total urbanization of society, according to which the industrial society would be transformed, as part of the same process of industrialization, into a post-industrial society. Lefebvre (1972) sees

Industrialization as a stage of urbanization, as a moment, an intermediary, an instrument. So in the process of industrialization-urbanization, it is the second term that becomes dominant, after a period where the first one prevailed (p. 45).

In that same ten-year period, Harvey (1977) defines the configuration of the urban revolution as a perspective: "Evidence suggests that the forces of urbanization are emerging with great vigor and that they tend to occupy a central place in world history. Urbanization has reached a worldwide scale. The urbanization of the countryside continues rapidly" (p. 329). And more recently, Soja (2008) based on an interpretation of the impact of the re-engineering of the industrialization process in the contemporary city, analyzes the transition from the modern industrial metropolis to the postmodern metropolis, or postmetropolis.

As we have seen so far, in modern capitalist society the industrialization and urbanization processes develop concomitantly. In this industrial society, with the urban crisis at the end of the 1960s –as is the case of the events of May1968 in Paris- a process of revolution arises on the way to the configuration of an urban society, although its problems under the capitalist system of production are intrinsically related to the process of industrial production, as is evident with the environmental issues.

The third industrial revolution breaks down, among other reasons, because of the process of urbanization of society which, one way or another, is the root cause of the mortgage crisis in the United States in 2007, due to the collapse of the housing bubble, and which in 2008 becomes a serious economic and financial crisis of an international scope. Thus, according to Schwab (2016), founder and CEO of the World Economic Forum, at the end of the 2010 decade the fourth industrial revolution begins to unfold. Although it is based on the previous one, it is mainly characterized by the combination of different technologies connected through what has become known as the Internet of Things (IoT), developed around the physical, digital and biological fields.

In this scenario, the Forum creates in 2017 the first Center for the Fourth Industrial Revolution in San Francisco with the aim of promoting public-private cooperation in the governance of emerging technologies and risk management. By 2018, three more centers had been established around the world. And in 2019, the one created in Medellin, the first in Latin America, ran by Ruta N, a public-private innovation and business corporation, stands out. This designation is part of another type of international recognition granted to the city in recent years, as part of the urban marketing strategy at an international level, led by the Mayor's Office, through the Agencia de Cooperación e Inversión, ACI (Agency for Cooperation and Investment), among other entities.

This marketing strategy has sold internationally the image of a city transformed thanks to its urban development planning and management process, in a strategic and collaborative way, which began in the 1990s and goes up to the present. This transformation happens precisely in the context of the fourth urban revolution, in the terms explained above, as the total urbanization of society. It is already commonplace to say that in the 21st century humanity will reverse the relationship between the countryside and the cities, with cities becoming home to more than half of the world's population.

But unfortunately, Schwab’s proposal on the emergence of the fourth industrial revolution as part of a process of global productive reorganization and the great expectations brought about by the creation in 2019 of the center in Medellín, stands in contrast, among the city’s yet unresolved issues, with the growing concern about the environmental problems caused by the accumulation in the air of a mixture of atmospheric pollutants that significantly affect public health.

Among the harmful pollutants released into the atmosphere by human activities are particulate matter (PM), defined as particles of any finely divided solid or liquid material, which are dispersed and removed from the air. This material is classified into coarse particles (PM10) and fine particles (PM2.5). The latter consist of compounds generally associated with acidic particles by fossil energy combustion, among other processes.

At present, Medellín's air quality crisis is caused by the accumulation of these dangerous particles of material, specifically PM2.5 which, as demonstrated by the competent environmental authority, the Valle de Aburrá Metropolitan Area (AMVA), comes from fossil fuel transport emissions (80 %) and, to a lesser extent, from the service sector and industrial production (20 %) which, in the region, in many cases, still use coal, such as the factories of the first Industrial Revolution (Área Metropolitana del Valle de Aburrá, 2017).

From the issues covered here, we see how generally some social processes come late to Latin America, considered a developing region, in relation to the so-called developed countries. In this sense, it should be stressed that the forces at work associated to the beginning of the industrialization process appeared here a century later than in Europe and the United States, at the end of the 19th and during the first half of the 20th centuries. And although the advances linked to the second industrial revolution also entered the region at this time, this revolution developed in the region, in relation to its main sector, the car industry, only in the second half of the 20th, when the developed countries of Europe, along with the United States and Japan were already well into their third industrial revolution, whose innovations also came late (although today, thanks to globalization, they are reaching us increasingly faster).

In this way it is possible to explain why, when through social networks and the media we have information and knowledge about new technological and scientific developments elsewhere, our daily lives are still facing problems that seem to be from a remote past, and that in deed in some cases are. In this sense, air pollution is an example of an urban problem much more related to the first and second industrial revolutions than to the third and even less so to the fourth. Thus, after two decades into the 21st century, without Latin America having been able to solve its problems related to the first two industrial revolutions and, moreover, without having developed the third in its different extents, Medellín is now a center for the development of the fourth industrial revolution.

This statement does not seek to question the designation of Medellín as a center for the fourth industrial revolution or its potential to contribute to its development in the international context. Rather, it is a matter of highlighting the need to articulate efforts to produce the environmental and urban public policies needed to overcome, among others, the problem of air quality in Medellín and the Valle de Aburrá, in governance scenarios in which the different State agencies and organized society in their multiple and complex forms have a role to play.

In short, both overcoming this type of problem, still related to the first urban revolutions, as is the case of environmental pollution, and the development of the different dimensions of the third, could contribute to a true unfolding of the Fourth Industrial Revolution in the city, given the close relationship that there is, as we saw at the beginning, between the process of urbanization and that of industrialization.

REFERENCES