Received: January 29, 2024
Accepted: April 9, 2024
The objective of this article is to critically analyze the idea of the dehumanization of nursing care due to the increasing technologization and technicalization. To examine this idea, it proposes a philosophical analysis of the concepts of technique, technology, nursing care, and dehumanization, establishing three thematic axes: the dehumanization of care, care, and technique as an ontological conception of the human. It is based on philosophical references regarding technique, especially the fable of Hyginus in the work of Heidegger, who offers an interpretation that seeks to integrate technique and care as part of a symbiotic ontology. In conclusion, it is highlighted that technique and care are not opposite concepts: on the contrary, both are constitutive of the human nature and, therefore, blaming technique and technology exclusively for dehumanization is certainly contradictory.
Keywords: healthcare, nursing philosophy, philosophy of technique, humanization of care.
el presente artículo tiene como objetivo analizar críticamente la idea de la deshumanización del cuidado de enfermería debido a la creciente tecnologización y tecnificación. Para examinar esta afirmación se propone un análisis filosófico de los conceptos de técnica, tecnología, cuidado de enfermería y deshumanización, estableciendo tres ejes temáticos: la deshumanización del cuidado, el cuidado y la técnica como concepción ontológica de lo humano. Se parte de referentes filosóficos de la técnica, en especial, la fábula de Higinio en la obra de Heidegger, quien ofrece una interpretación que busca integrar la técnica y el cuidado como parte de una ontología simbiótica. Como conclusión se destaca que la técnica y el cuidado no son conceptos opuestos: por el contrario, ambos son constitutivos de la naturaleza humana, por lo tanto, culpar exclusivamente a la técnica y a la tecnología de la deshumanización resulta ciertamente contradictorio.
Palabras clave: cuidado de la salud, filosofía de enfermería, filosofía de la técnica, humanización del cuidado.
The dehumanization of healthcare and health services has emerged as a major challenge in recent years. In response, some authors, such as
The advent of the COVID-19 pandemic has led to an exponential increase in the use of technology-mediated health services, commonly referred to as telehealth (
The thesis that we intend to support in this manuscript is that healthcare would not be possible without technique and, in contemporary times, it would not be rational to forego technology. Therefore, technique and technology are necessary for healthcare, yet they are not sufficient. Moreover, technique is inherent to care and care per se is a technical gesture. In fact, technocare could be defined today as an attitude and action of the human beings who care for others. Based on this conceptual background of technique and care, the dehumanization of care could be seen as a contradiction, rooted in instrumentalist or alienating visions of technology.
Thus, this manuscript is configured as a philosophical reflection on the dehumanization of nursing care in a context of increasing technification. For its construction, a descriptive qualitative approach is adopted within the framework of documentary research. Consequently, an analysis of the key concepts that underpin the study, including technique, technology, nursing care, and dehumanization, is first proposed. Subsequently, Heidegger’s interpretation of the Hyginus’ fable is analyzed to understand the relationship between technique and care from an ontological perspective. This analysis allows the establishment of a connection between the mythical dimension and the current reality of nursing care in the context of technification.
Based on the conceptual analysis and the hermeneutic interpretation, this manuscript questions the notion of dehumanization of care as an inevitable consequence of technification. Instead, it proposes an alternative vision that highlights the possibility of a symbiotic ontology between technique and care, where both elements complement and enrich each other.
In the preparation of this manuscript, numerous bibliographical sources were consulted, including books, scientific papers, and other documents relevant to the research topic. Materials related to Heidegger, philosophy of technique, and nursing epistemology were particularly significant. It should be noted that this study is based on philosophical reflection rather than empirical research, so neither quantitative nor qualitative data are presented. Nevertheless, the rigorous conceptual analysis, hermeneutic interpretation, and argumentative construction make a substantial contribution to the ongoing debate on the dehumanization of nursing care in the age of technification.
Some precedents of the so-called dehumanization of healthcare include the mechanistic approach (which breaks down the whole into parts to facilitate the study of isolated elements while ignoring the systematicity of the biological, psychological, and social dimensions), biological reductionism (which reduces the health–disease process to the biological sphere), the division of labor, the subspecialization of medicine, neoliberal economics, and technoscience (
These conceptions are related to three critical assessments of the philosophy of technique:
The first is the argument of the hierarchical order of existence between the natural and the artificial, with the natural being ontologically superior to the artificial. In this sense, “natural” healthcare is perceived to have a higher ontological status than care mediated by artifacts. The second assessment refers to the axiological neutrality of technique. In this view, artifacts are conceived as mere tools at the service of humans, while technique is regarded as an instrument of power and domination, i.e., as a political form, mechanism, strategy, or device to uphold existing power structures. Finally, the third assessment, from the perspective of critical social theory, asserts that artifacts, mechanization, and machines, especially modern ones, are not only inherently political but also serve as instruments for maintaining and defending certain structures of power and domination over nature and human beings. The function of the philosophy of technique, therefore, is to denounce this state of affairs (
Nevertheless, it is important to acknowledge that, since the dawn of medicine, technique has been critical. The discovery of fire in the Neolithic period enabled human communities to significantly enhance and expand their food supply. Moreover, the practice of burial and the establishment of agricultural settlements during that same period notably modified morbidity and mortality rates, with certain diseases becoming more prevalent while others declined. It can therefore be argued that technique has played a pivotal role in the health–disease process and in the consolidation of medicine as a practice (
In nursing science, numerous conceptual frameworks have addressed care and the role of nurses in it. For example, the health–disease concept introduced by Florence Nightingale—who is considered a pioneering figure in the establishment of modern nursing as both a discipline and a profession—is particularly enlightening. Nightingale defined illness as the way nature rids itself of effects or conditions that have interfered with health. Moreover, she explained that health was not merely a state of well-being but also encompassed the capacity to effectively use all of one’s energy, as well as one’s technical (empirical, artistic) and emotional abilities (
Another illustrative case is that of Callista Roy, a nurse who developed a comprehensive epistemological framework for nursing care using the adaptation model. This model is based on the postulates of Bertalanffy’s general systems theory and Helson’s adaptation theory (
From the nursing disciplinary framework, numerous examples illustrate the role of technique in its instrumental and sociopolitical forms. Particularly, Nightingale employed statistical methods to demonstrate the correlation between the environment and the health–disease process (
Recognizing that nursing care has given a practical and epistemic sense to the technical dimension does not imply ignoring the challenges faced. These challenges include the erosion of nursing professionals’ rationality, the fragmentation of care time (
To be more precise in the discourse, terms such as a decline in the quality of care, neglect of care, and crisis of values among healthcare professionals could be employed. These phenomena are multifactorial and can be attributed to numerous factors that include nurses’ harsh working conditions (
Examples from professional experience, ranging from triage in emergency services to fields of action in community settings, can illustrate these points. In the case of triage, the nursing staff carries out a rapid, concise, and problem-oriented assessment to prioritize and classify the severity of patients and optimize the use of available resources. For such assessment, scales such as NEWS2 (
Moreover, it is not reasonable to consider the human being without acknowledging the role of technique. Following
Recognizing contemporary technique and technology as inherent to human existence does not imply abandoning the critical perspective. In fact, it is essential to continually refine the mechanisms for both external and internal evaluation of technology, especially considering their short- and medium-term consequences. According to
Could this way of adapting the environment for survival and satisfaction of needs be considered a form of care? Or could technique, as enabler and constituent of culture, facilitate and constitute healthcare?
An ontological reading of care in Heidegger, through Hyginus’ fable, has significantly influenced nursing by describing the essentiality of care in the configuration of the human (
Once when ‘Care1 ’ was crossing a river, she saw some clay; she thoughtfully took up a piece and began to shape it. While she was meditating on what she had made, Jupiter came by. ‘Care’ asked him to give it spirit, and this he gladly granted. But when she wanted her name to be bestowed upon it, he forbade this, and demanded that it be given his name instead. While ‘Care’ and Jupiter were disputing, Earth arose and desired that her own name be conferred on the creature, since she had furnished it with part of her body. They asked Saturn to be their arbiter, and he made the following decision, which seemed a just one: ‘Since you, Jupiter, have given its spirit, you shall receive that spirit at its death; and since you, Earth, have given its body, you shall receive its body. But since ‘Care’ first shaped this creature, she shall possess it as long as it lives. And because there is now a dispute among you as to its name, let it be called ‘homo’, for it is made out of humus (earth). (Heidegger, 1962, p. 198 )
The Heideggerian interpretation emphasizes that care is not merely a potentiality of the human, the original condition of all that is and of “that to which human Dasein belongs for ‘its lifetime’. [Instead, care also] emerges in connection with the familiar way of taking man as compounded of body (earth) and spirit” (
Building on Heidegger’s proposal,
Care, therefore, is not an occasional action but a continuous and dedicated process that persists alongside the individual throughout their lifetime. Care encompasses more than just physical aspects; it involves sustaining and nurturing the growth and realization of human potential in its entirety. Boff also proposes care as a principle of precaution and prevention, as a loving gesture and a protective activity towards the common home. It is precisely this conception of care as a gesture, as a continuous act of gestation, as the very realization of the human which has prompted a reinterpretation of the myth described in Being and Time (
While walking along the river, Care observes and carefully examines the place. This initial form of care could be analogous to what is referred to in nursing as assessment. As defined by the
From another perspective, the ontogeny of the genus Homo was constituted by two fundamental aspects: the development of a specialized physio-anatomy (bipedal posture, pincer grip, and functional and anatomical development of the frontal lobe) and the adoption of technical selection as a mechanism for the acquisition of complexity (
In the context of nursing, caring requires assessing the patient and their environment. For this purpose, semiotechnics—or maneuvers of exploration and physical examination, such as inspection, palpation, auscultation, and percussion—are utilized. However, to effectively perform this assessment, it is essential to establish a helpful or therapeutic relationship with the patient, through values such as compassion, respect, and empathy (
In Heidegger’s myth, Care is depicted as meditating, reflecting on her observations. This contemplation evokes something within her that moves her to perform a technical act and mold clay with her hands to become the efficient cause of the human. She acts as an intermediary between the eternity of gods and the material finitude of human beings. Another fundamental aspect in this passage is the dispute for the name, the naming, the linguistic baptism as an ontological part of the human, within which technique also resides. Language and the forging of the human through care may be, in Heidegger’s terms, a mode of “unhiding”.
Technique, according to
Assessing, in the sense of observing, perceiving, and interacting with the environment, is a biological phenomenon. We are constantly and inevitably assessing. In the context of nursing, it is worth asking: if caring requires assessment, and assessment requires the use of physical examination techniques, could it then be said that without technique there is no care?
In this regard,
Patient experience is a key factor in evaluating the quality of nursing care and heavily relies on nurses’ ability to communicate, inform, provide timely support, and extend care beyond routine procedures (
According to
This is only a glimpse of the phenomenon in the context of nursing. An alternative perspective can be delineated in terms of the hominization and humanization of the human being in relation to technique and care. As explained by
The concept of humanization is more complex, especially because there is no clear consensus on the term. The verb humanize refers to the process of making or converting something into human, civilizing it. From its root humus, which refers to the earth, it has a somewhat contrary meaning to that of a divine being. Similar references can be identified in the Hebrew Adam (man), Adamah (earth) (
Conceiving the human as embodying both Eros and Thanatos could offer a new conceptualization of the term. However, even if we persist in the idea that healthcare and nursing care can be humanized by enhancing the so-called soft skills, the assertion that technique and technology are the main obstacles to humanization and the first steps towards dehumanization makes no sense. In this regard, three arguments related to contemporary technological conceptions could be put forward (
Do human beings really lose their essence as thinking, relational, and inherently flawed subjects because of their interaction with artifacts and technology? Or, on the contrary, are we, as humans, so malleable, that we transform and are transformed by artifacts and technical actions like the clay in the myth?
In a technical world, it is imperative that care and technique complement each other. Regardless of how technical the world becomes—and even if we can speak of technopersons today—humans beings are creatures who care and need to be cared for (
Technological progress has substantially improved living conditions. Particularly,
In the field of nursing care, the history of various artifacts and tools could also be traced. An illustrative example is that of syringes, which have been constructed from feathers, barrel bellows, reusable glass and plastic, and even catheters and pumps equipped with sensors. Syringes represent a conceptual development in healthcare, as they introduced concepts such as injectable, injection, intravenous, intramuscular, and even a specific field of knowledge, namely injectology (
As a practice, it is impossible to conceive of nursing as non-technical. Even traditional forms of care involve specific techniques, including the preparation of concoctions and the recital of prayers by shamans or the application of strokes and massages by doulas
From another perspective, care employs language, physical contact, observation, and listening. In nursing, narrative, literary, and artistic methodologies are widely recognized as therapeutic and cathartic tools. Authors such as Watson and Peplau (as cited in
This relationship between care and technique is dialogical. Just as care is per se a technical gesture, technique, from a possibilist point of view, implies care—a special way of relating to the world. Care is thus essential for making technology a possibility that is coherent with life itself. Technology, in turn, expands our space of possibilities. As explained by
It is, however, necessary to recognize and leverage these possibilities. Precisely at this juncture, care, as rationality and relational emotionality, takes on a superlative value: It is the element that makes it technically feasible what is possible today and what will seem impossible tomorrow.
The advent of artificial intelligence and its increasing implementation in healthcare settings and nursing care (
Care and technique are neither opposites nor contradictory concepts; they are both intrinsic to the human condition. It is therefore contradictory to speak of dehumanization of humans and care as a result of technique and technology—a perspective particularly popular in nursing science. The idea that the technification of nursing care inevitably leads to dehumanization is a simplistic and reductionist view that fails to capture the complexity of the relationship between these two elements. Consequently, a possibilistic approach to technology and a conceptualization of care and technique are necessary to acknowledge that both Eros and Thanatos converge in the human nature.
Technology makes care possible, and care enables more equitable and responsible technical action and technological production. Technique and technology should not be regarded as threats to quality care but as ontological constituents of it and, in this sense, they configure a horizon of possibilities for care. Likewise, innovation itself does not lead to a loss of sensitivity; on the contrary, sensitivity fosters innovation. Considering this, a reinterpretation of the myth of care to acknowledge technique as part of human ontology can be crucial; not to deify it after the death of God but to allow care to shape the clay under the divine chronometer’s gaze and temporal judgment. Because care is the possibility of existence, even of technical and technological existence.
The authors declare that they have no financial, professional, or personal conflicts of interest that may inappropriately influence the results achieved or the interpretations proposed.
All authors contributed to the conceptual development of ideas, the design of concepts, the insights gained, and the drafting and final version of this article.