Received: MArch 16, 2024
Accepted: July 12, 2024
Nowadays, the didactics of experimental sciences is interested in scientific culture and scientific literacy—beyond their differences and conceptual relationships—because they have strategic purposes in science education. In response, this study identifies and categorizes elements that currently hinder the teaching of scientific culture and scientific literacy in experimental sciences. The PRISMA protocol for systematic reviews was applied to search the Scopus, Web of Science, EBSCOhost, and SciELO databases using strategic keywords, as well as inclusion and exclusion criteria. This search retrieved 12 articles that underwent thematic content analysis using Atlas.ti software. Based on this analysis, hindering elements were identified and classified into methodological, epistemological, and socio-cultural. The most common category was methodological, a trend that indicates that science education is more interested in practical and experiential problems. It is concluded that the problem of developing scientific culture and scientific literacy in school settings is mainly associated with practical, phenomenological, cognitive, and disciplinary aspects related to a deficit-based approach, which supports traditional views and models of scientific culture and scientific literacy. These aspects coincide with the predominance of a traditional approach to teaching experimental sciences. As a result, teachers should receive epistemology and didactics training that addresses teaching in a more comprehensive manner based on emerging didactic approaches that respond to their context.
Keywords: scientific literacy, scientific culture, science education, science teachers, systematic review.
la cultura y la alfabetización científicas, más allá de sus diferencias y relaciones conceptuales, en la actualidad son planteamientos de interés para la didáctica de las ciencias experimentales debido a que tienen objetivos estratégicos en el campo de la educación científica. Frente a ello, esta investigación identifica y categoriza elementos que en la actualidad obstaculizan el desarrollo de estos dos constructos en la enseñanza de las ciencias experimentales. A partir de la búsqueda en las bases de datos Scopus, Web of Science, EBSCOhost y SciELO con descriptores estratégicos, junto a la consideración de criterios de inclusión y exclusión, la aplicación del protocolo PRISMA para revisiones sistemáticas permitió incluir doce artículos que fueron sometidos a un análisis de contenido temático con el software ATLAS.ti. Del análisis se identifican elementos obstaculizadores, siendo los más recurrentes los caracterizados como metodológicos, junto a epistemológicos y socioculturales, tendencia esta que indica un mayor interés por los problemas de naturaleza práctica y experiencial en la enseñanza. Se concluye que el problema del desarrollo de la cultura y alfabetización científica en el escenario escolar está principalmente asociado a lo práctico, fenoménico, cognitivo y disciplinar, lo cual está relacionado con una visión fundamentada en el déficit, planteamiento que soporta las visiones y modelos tradicionales de cultura y alfabetización científicas, aspectos que coinciden con al predominio de una enseñanza tradicional de las ciencias experimentales. En consecuencia, se recomienda una formación epistemológica y didáctica del profesorado que aborde la enseñanza de manera más amplia con base en planteamientos didácticos emergentes que respondan a dicho contexto.
Palabras clave: alfabetización científica, cultura científica, enseñanza de las ciencias, profesores de ciencias, revisión sistemática.
Nowadays, it is crucial for citizens to acquire basic scientific knowledge to cultivate a civic and critical perspective on science and its development, which, in turn, is essential for making informed decisions about everyday technological and scientific issues (
This is particularly important in light of the current global crisis, which encompasses environmental, economic, and social challenges. Addressing these challenges requires individuals with a critical and activist stance toward science, one that is aligned with other cultural spheres. Therefore, the promotion of scientific culture and literacy is imperative (
Scientific culture includes information related to and consistent with scientific activity. It consists of two main components: science itself and the information (whether representational, practical, or evaluative) that is part of a group’s general culture and relates to science, even if not directly involved in scientific practice (
For more than four decades, significant efforts have been made to systematize these concepts, revealing their conceptual diversity (
There are currently three perspectives on scientific literacy. Vision I, based on the deficit model, views science as an orthodox canon, and scientific literacy is approached prospectively, with the goal of training future scientists or individuals who understand and value scientific knowledge and practices (
In general, envisioning a science education that fosters these two constructs means developing critical thinking about scientific matters (
These challenges outlined by
In light of the above, this study aims to conduct a systematic review to identify and characterize the factors that hinder the development of scientific culture and literacy in the context of experimental science didactics. The purpose of the review is to not only gather current data on the topic but also to point out specific issues that can guide future research in the field. In addition, it aims to offer valuable theoretical insights that can inform teachers’ educational practices.
This study followed a methodological approach based on established standards for systematic reviews and meta-analyses, adhering to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) protocol (
| Databases | Search strings |
| WoS | (((TS=("scientific literacy")) OR TS=("scientific culture")) AND TS=(didactic)) AND TS=(education) |
| Scopus | ( TITLE-ABS-KEY ( "scientific culture" ) OR TITLE-ABS-KEY ( "scientific literacy" ) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY ( education ) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY ( didactic ) ) |
| SciELO | (scientific culture) OR (scientific culture) AND (education) AND (didactic) |
| EBSCOhost | Ti (“scientific culture”) OR (“scientific literacy”) AND Ti (education) AND Ti (didactic) |
The initial search yielded 192 documents, which were then screened using specific inclusion criteria. To be considered, the documents had to be open-access scientific articles written in Spanish, English, or Portuguese and published between 2019 and 2023. These criteria were designed to ensure a focus on current issues in the field. As a result of this screening process, a final set of 70 articles was selected (see Figure 1). These choices were made because certain document types, such as books, book chapters, and reviews, represented less than 5% of the 192 documents initially retrieved. Additionally, it was important to ensure full access to the selected documents for in-depth analysis. Also, the period from 2019 to 2023 was chosen to guarantee the use of up-to-date data.
Duplicate articles were removed using the Rayyan tool (n = 12). The suitability of the remaining articles was assessed based on the following inclusion and exclusion criteria:
1) Articles needed to address the concepts of scientific culture and/or scientific literacy within the context of education. Eighteen articles that did not focus on formal education were excluded.
2) Articles had to be related to the teaching or the didactics of experimental sciences. Twelve articles that did not provide information on this were excluded.
3) Only articles based on empirical or field research were included. Sixteen articles classified as monographs, reviews, essays, or non-applied proposals were excluded.
The eligibility process was carried out meticulously in two stages. In the first stage, the titles and abstracts of the remaining articles were reviewed, resulting in the removal of 30 articles. In the second stage, a comprehensive review of the full documents, with a particular focus on the methodology, led to the exclusion of an additional 16 articles. To ensure methodological rigor and minimize bias, a second researcher independently reviewed 20% of the remaining 58 articles, achieving a 91% agreement rate.
The twelve selected articles were subjected to a thematic content analysis, focusing on the findings, discussion, and conclusions. This approach facilitated the development of a coding and classification system through an inductive process, enabling the grouping of information based directly on the content described in the documents (
From the twelve selected articles, the following information was extracted: author(s), year of publication, the problems addressed, the employed methodologies, and the explicit or implicit didactic challenges identified in each study (see Table 2).
| Author, year, indexing | Problem addressed | Methodology | Didactic element (challenge) |
| The need for a new approach to science education aligned with an inclusive and participatory social reality | Quantitative research/Exploratory and prospective study | Didactic decisions based on classroom experience rather than emerging theoretical models or approaches | |
| Scarce teacher training in didactics, coupled with poor planning of teaching processes | Learning experience | Insufficient constructivist and didactic teacher training | |
| Science teachers’ use of overly direct language and a school science discourse devoid of context | Qualitative research/Case study | Absence of a teacher-driven, autonomous narrative in science education processes | |
| Low relevance of science as a field of interest for students | Quantitative research/Learning experience | Low student motivation and interest in science | |
| Deterministic science teaching processes lacking sequences that foster early scientific literacy | Qualitative exploratory research/Pedagogical intervention | Limited, discipline-driven teaching processes | |
| Lack of motivation and perception of chemistry linked to inadequate knowledge dissemination strategies | Mixed-method research/Case study | Ineffective didactic strategies for disseminating scientific knowledge | |
| Gaps between cross-cultural perspectives | Qualitative research/Participatory action research | Intercultural challenges in experimental science didactics | |
| The need for a scientific culture model recognizing personal, social, and environmental values | Qualitative research/Narrative | Transmissive knowledge models and limited understanding of participants in the teaching process | |
| Students’ limited socio–scientific knowledge influenced by weak argumentative synthesis | Quantitative research/Quasi-experiment | Poor argumentative synthesis and inadequate socio–scientific knowledge | |
| A chemistry teaching process devoid of context hinders the appropriation of scientific knowledge, leading to poor conceptualization of scientific concepts in relation to students' surroundings. | Qualitative research/Quasi-experiment | Weak contextualization of scientific content | |
| Science education gained increased prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic, as health measures necessitated significant changes in teaching practices for both teachers and students. This shift highlighted the need to develop effective and appropriate learning sequences. | Learning experience | Teacher preparation for co-designing effective teaching processes | |
| Textbooks in scientific culture and literacy often lack content and information related to bioethics. | Quantitative research/Field study | Scarce bioethical content in textbooks and their strong grounding in socio-scientific perspectives |
In the second stage of the review, a thematic content analysis was conducted to identify key citations, generate codes, and categorize hindering elements. This inductive approach resulted in three main categories: methodological, epistemological, and sociocultural elements. Additionally, the use of ATLAS.ti was instrumental in this process, allowing for the creation of a semantic network that integrated information from all twelve articles and provided a systematic perspective on the findings. The details of the three categories are discussed below, followed by the overall results of the analysis.
The analysis revealed that, in teaching experimental sciences, teachers often rely on empirical approaches despite the availability of emerging didactic models. This tendency is primarily attributed to a lack of adequate training in didactics (
The identified methodological barriers include those highlighted by
In this same vein,
Lastly,
The analysis of the reviewed articles revealed various epistemological issues. A key concern is the lack of reflection and debate on the teaching of science within formal education.
Another obstacle is the dominance of individual values over a more collective, communal, and global perspective (
In three of the reviewed articles, sociocultural issues were also identified.
Figure 2 shows how these sociocultural issues intersect with the other concerns, demonstrating that fostering scientific culture and literacy in science education requires moving beyond the monolithic discourse on science, technology, and scientific knowledge, integrating these fields more effectively with other aspects of human culture (
This thematic content analysis revealed a predominant focus on practical and phenomenological aspects in the literature, as evidenced by the greater number of methodological obstacles identified. In contrast, epistemological and sociocultural challenges receive comparatively less attention in the reviewed documents (see Figure 2). Additionally, few studies address more than one category, suggesting a lack of interconnectedness and depth in the research. Finally, the analysis highlighted a pervasive deficiency in perspectives on scientific culture and literacy. For instance,
Inductively, the analysis identified the dominance of methodological elements, revealing that current issues in science teaching remain tied to didacticism without a theoretical framework that would provide a perspective on the methodological approach. This reflects a phenomenological approach to science teaching (
This perspective is limiting when considering the nature of experimental science didactics as a discipline.
The analysis also revealed epistemological barriers, as identified in the studies by
Overall, this review shows that attention to scientific culture and literacy tends to focus on methodological aspects, often neglecting epistemological and sociocultural dimensions. The studies reviewed frequently adopt an eclectic approach to these concepts. Regarding scientific culture, they lean toward canonical and contextual models (
This review categorized obstacles in teaching experimental sciences into three main types: methodological, epistemological, and sociocultural. It further highlighted the dominance of traditional didactic models and teaching approaches as the primary barrier in the development of the constructs under analysis. Drawing on theoretical models of scientific culture and the various perspectives of scientific literacy, the analysis suggests a prevailing deficit-based perspective. In this view, the perceived absence of specific elements—whether cognitive, methodological, or dimensional—is framed as a fundamental issue contributing to the problem (
To address these challenges, it is essential to move beyond merely adding or incorporating elements into the teaching framework—akin to adding reactants in a chemical reaction to observe the outcome. Instead, there should be a deeper focus on interpreting and reflecting on the foundational elements underpinning the adopted vision of school science education. This entails giving greater attention to the epistemological and sociocultural factors that hinder or complicate efforts to foster scientific literacy. These factors, which are inherently transversal to science education, are highlighted in this research as the studies reviewed do not specifically define or limit their focus to particular contexts, modalities, or educational levels. In light of this, it is recommended that both initial and ongoing training for experimental science teachers treat science didactics as a distinct and complex discipline essential to teacher preparation, rather than a simple combination of disciplinary knowledge and pedagogy (
The main author would like to express gratitude to Chile’s National Agency for Research and Development (ANID).
The authors declare that they have no financial, professional, or personal conflicts of interest that could influence the results or interpretations presented in this study.
Francisco Pérez Rodríguez and Zenahir Siso Pavón conceptualized the research and definedthe methodology. The database search, document screening, and evaluation were carried out by Francisco Pérez Rodríguez. The analysis was conducted by Zenahir Siso Pavón, Lourdes Aragón, and Francisco Pérez Rodríguez. The original draft was written and edited by Sebastián Donoso Díaz and Francisco Pérez Rodríguez. The supervision of the work was handled by Zenahir Siso Pavón and Lourdes Aragón.