Received: May 28, 2024
Accepted: October 28, 2024
This paper aims to foster discussion on the critical role of social interaction in blended learning, emphasizing its potential to guide technology integration in higher education as a means to overcome its instrumental bias. To achieve this, the study reviews the concepts of technology integration and social interaction and presents an analysis of ChatGPT’s use in universities. Additionally, it examines three key results from a systematic literature review on interaction in blended learning. The findings highlight a predominant focus on implementing technologies and learning approaches; the interactions between students and their teachers and peers; and the growing interest in student-related factors such as motivation, attitudes, commitment, and collaboration. In short, the study underscores that human transactions—grounded in social interaction—enable the exchange of meanings, which furthers the transformation of learning environments. This transformation is essential for addressing the challenges faced by higher education, including ethical training, intellectual production, and the development of human skills.
Keywords: blended learning, higher education, technology integration, artificial intelligence, social interaction.
El presente artículo tuvo como objetivo promover la discusión sobre la importancia de la interacción social en el blended learning, con el fin de integrar las tecnologías en la educación superior, considerándolo como una de las posibles alternativas para superar su sesgo instrumental. Para alcanzar este objetivo, se revisaron los conceptos de integración tecnológica e interacción social, para luego analizar el caso de ChatGPT en las universidades, así como tres de los resultados de una revisión sistemática de la literatura sobre el estudio de la interacción en el blended learning, la cual permitió visibilizar el interés predominante por la implementación de tecnologías y enfoques de aprendizaje, las interacciones de los estudiantes con sus docentes y pares, y facilitó reconocer que una de las tendencias investigativas en la interacción social está centrada en las características de los estudiantes, particularmente con su motivación, actitudes, compromiso y trabajo con otros. En definitiva, las transacciones humanas, desde la interacción social, permiten la transmisión de significados que potencializan la transformación de los entornos de aprendizaje, ayudando a afrontar los retos de la educación superior, como la formación ética, la producción intelectual y el desarrollo de las habilidades humanas.
Palabras clave: blended learning, educación superior, integración tecnológica, inteligencia artificial, interacción social.
In recent years, education has transitioned from face-to-face to distance, online, and Blended Learning
(BL) models, driven by technological advancements that facilitate teacher–student interaction in the
learning process (
The transition toward technology-mediated models has increasingly emphasized social
interactions, particularly as concerns grow over how human connections may be threatened or transformed in
digital environments.
Since technology is an extension of human capability rather than an external threat, it
can be directed toward creative and constructive purposes. However, this requires an ethical approach and
policies that ensure its responsible use and democratization (
Given that learning is deeply rooted in social interaction, it is crucial to examine how
technology integration in BL impacts these dynamics. To contribute to this discussion, the following
section reviews key concepts related to technology integration and social interaction. This is followed by
an analysis of ChatGPT’s role in BL, along with findings from a systematic review (
The Horizon Report (
Although many institutions were forced to adopt hybrid and remote learning models during
the pandemic, the Horizon Report (
However, successful technology integration is not achieved merely through the use of
digital tools. Instead, it depends on the adoption of BL models that facilitate meaningful interaction
aligned with specific learning objectives. As
The rise of new technologies has fostered hyperconnectivity, transforming individuals into informational
beings with unprecedented ubiquity, connectivity, and accessibility. Nonetheless, in the field of
education, there remains a gap between the rapid advancement of technology and the pace of pedagogical
adaptation and reflection (
From the perspective of symbolic interactionism, interaction is understood as a process
of meaning-making between individuals. This process not only enables people to anticipate responses and
recognize social roles but also helps them understand their own behavioral patterns in specific contexts (
However,
According to this view, limiting teacher–student interaction to synchronous or asynchronous exchanges overlooks other essential forms of interaction, such as those involving non-human agents. These differing perspectives highlight the importance of aligning interaction models with specific learning objectives. In turn, these interactions align with specific BL models, which are adapted to students’ needs at varying levels of technology integration.
AI has been evolving for over fifty years. The ability of a machine to simulate conversation and adapt
its responses to context is the result of deliberate efforts that have significantly impacted various
human activities. ChatGPT, a generative pre-trained transformer, gained one million users within its first
five days after launching in November 2022. Within two months, this number reached 100 million (
Although technology, especially AI, is recognized for its benefits in education, academic
discussions have focused on its impact on intellectual production. The debate is polarized between those
who believe generative AI could replace human intellectual output (
Some publishers have rejected AI-generated content as a form of authorship (
In education, ChatGPT is used for generating research ideas, formulating search
equations, summarizing content, translating texts, and even drafting articles. In applied fields, it
assists with software debugging, clinical summaries, and radiological decision-making (
The usefulness of ChatGPT in programming education has also been recognized (
Even though ChatGPT facilitates personalized learning, some critics argue that it cannot
replace a teacher. They highlight its biases, its inability to verify information, and its lack of
awareness of its conversational partner. Because it generates responses instantaneously without deeper
engagement, it cannot function as an expert guiding students within their zone of proximal development (
Ethical concerns have also been raised regarding its use in academia, particularly in
relation to plagiarism and fraud in online assessments (
From a regulatory perspective, these concerns highlight the need for clear pedagogical
policies, along with their governance and implementation (
The integration of technology into education has been expanding in Colombia, particularly in BL within
higher education, with the number of programs holding official accreditation increasing from 33 in 2020 to
248 by 2024 (
Such study followed three phases: planning, review, and reporting (
The review phase involved a rigorous assessment of original studies using a predefined
structure that facilitated information synthesis and ensured the reliability and applicability of
findings. This phase consisted of five stages: identification, selection, evaluation, extraction, and
synthesis. A search strategy (see Table 1) was developed using the descriptors blended
learning, interaction, and higher education in English across two major academic databases: Web of Science
(WoS) and Scopus. Inclusion criteria required that documents be classified as “articles” and contain the
selected descriptors in their titles, abstracts, or keywords. In WoS, the enriched article option was
excluded, as these publications include additional resources that were not analyzed in the review (
| Databases | Web of Science | Scopus |
| Time span | All years | |
| Consultation date | April 10, 2023 | |
| Document type | Any type | |
| Journal type | Any type | |
| Search field | Title, abstract, keywords | |
| Search strings | B-learning (All Fields) OR Blended AND Learning (All Fields) AND interaction AND (All Fields) higher AND educa-tion (All Fields) (Not Enriched Cited References) | (TITLE-ABS-KEY (B-learning) OR TITLE-ABS-KEY (Blended AND Learning) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY (interaction) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY (higher AND education)) |
| Search results | 652 | 515 |
| Total articles retrieved | 1167 | |
| Articles excluded | 387 | |
| Articles meeting inclusion criteria | 780 | |
| Duplicates removed using ToS | 122 | |
| Articles without duplicates | 658 | |
| Articles pre-selected by ToS | 98 | |
| Final selection using PageRank | 44 | |
| Research articles analyzed | 37 | |
| Review articles analyzed | 7 | |
Then, the selected articles underwent a deductive content analysis (
Regarding the keyword analysis in the 44 selected articles, ToS was used to identify
clusters of research topics. The software structured a network of nodes using the
Finally, in the third phase proposed by
The systematic review yielded three key findings. The first finding pertains to the main topics of research, which can be classified into three overarching themes. Although these themes may initially appear similar, a closer examination of the most frequently cited authors revealed nuanced distinctions between them. These themes encompass (i) implementation, (ii) teaching, and (iii) psychological characteristics.
The first theme (see Table 2), which exhibits the highest level of development, focuses on the implementation of BL. Research in this area primarily addresses technology integration, perceptions, and the outcomes associated with specific learning approaches following its adoption.
| Description | Most cited articles |
| Blended learning mediated by technology, focusing on students’ and teachers’ perceptions, course implementation in terms of time and physical and online spaces, and student performance |
|
The second theme (see Table 3) centers on teaching and encompasses both individual and collaborative learning activities. In contrast to the first theme, this category includes a smaller number of highly cited authors.
| Description | Most cited articles |
| Interaction in blended learning that supports teaching through both individual and collaborative activities mediated by technology |
|
Lastly, the third theme (see Table 4) explores the psychological dimensions of student interaction, particularly in terms of attitudes, motivation, and engagement. These aspects are closely linked to teacher feedback, as recognizing students’ psychological states allows educators to tailor their responses accordingly. For instance, if a teacher detects a lack of motivation among students, feedback may extend beyond task-related activities to include strategies aimed at enhancing motivation. Although this theme is associated with a smaller cluster of research compared to the previous one, it includes a higher number of cited authors.
| Description | Most cited articles |
| Blended learning from a psychological perspective, identifying key social interaction components (attitudes, motivation, engagement, and collaboration), as well as strategies employed by teachers to support students |
|
The second key finding of the review pertains to the types of interaction examined in the 44 analyzed
articles. Among the 37 research articles (see Table 5), the most frequently studied
interactions were those between teachers and students (
| Type of interaction | # of articles |
| Teacher–student interaction | 6 |
| Student–teacher–peer interaction | 6 |
| Social interaction | 4 |
| Constructivist interaction | 4 |
| Online interaction | 2 |
| Interaction with technology | 2 |
| Interaction with activities | 2 |
| Online–face-to-face interaction | 1 |
| Effective interaction | 1 |
| Interaction by educational level | 1 |
| Not mentioned directly | 8 |
Other studies have focused on different aspects of interaction, such as online and/or face-to-face
interaction (
In the seven review articles analyzed, interaction was examined from broader
perspectives. Some studies compared interaction in blended and face-to-face learning environments (
Finally, the third key finding of the review highlights emerging research trends, which
emphasize expanding the perspective on BL implementation by considering students’ learning processes and
individual characteristics. These trends focus on several key areas such as design in BL (
Technology integration in BL in higher education often reflects an instrumental bias, focusing mainly
on technology implementation (
A relevant example of this integration is the use of AI, particularly ChatGPT, as a
tool for personalized learning. While AI can enhance the instrumental aspects of teaching, it does not
replace the construction of shared meanings, which is a fundamental aspect of human interaction (
The way in which technology is integrated plays a central role in shaping
teacher–student and peer interactions, which, in turn, fosters learner autonomy (
Although learning can occur in environments that involve non-human interactions (
If integrated thoughtfully, the potential negative effects of technology can be
mitigated through clear regulatory frameworks that establish ethical guidelines and policies to govern
its use. Such measures are necessary to safeguard intellectual production while also fostering the
development of human skills, guaranteeing that technology implementation aligns with the educational
objectives of each BL model (
Ethical considerations, therefore, must extend beyond implementation to include
critical discussions on technology’s role in societal transformation and its impact on individuals’
quality of life. Rather than perceiving technological advancement as an unstoppable force, it is
essential to define minimum ethical standards that protect both intellectual production and human
integrity (
The systematic review revealed that research on interactions in BL has predominantly focused on technology implementation, emphasizing the importance of understanding participants’ perceptions, the differences between online and face-to-face interactions, and student performance, with many studies highlighting improved learning outcomes. Nevertheless, other key areas of interest have also emerged, particularly concerning teaching processes that prioritize the study of both individual and collective learning activities. Additionally, there is a growing focus on the psychological dimensions of interaction—such as motivation, attitudes, engagement, and collaboration—which underscores the role of social dynamics in shaping individual learning experiences. Interactions with teachers, tutors, and peers not only provide timely feedback but also foster learning and critical thinking.
Symbolic interactionism views, these approaches facilitate collective mental
constructions (
In this regard, social interaction plays a crucial role in mitigating the instrumental
bias associated with technology in education. While technology integration is essential, it is not
sufficient on its own to foster meaningful learning experiences. From the perspectives of symbolic
interactionism (
This discussion on social interaction in BL addresses the instrumental bias that emerges when technologies are assumed to replace teachers. This bias is particularly evident in studies that focus primarily on the adoption of technological tools while neglecting the broader formative challenges associated with ethical training, conscientious preparation, and critical thinking in the use of technology.
In BL, effective social interaction must take into account the specific characteristics of each educational context, which determine the type of blend—whether enabling, enhancing, or transforming. Relying solely on market factors, trends, or fleeting opportunities to justify the adoption of technology in higher education risks overlooking other dimensions of learning. From the perspective of symbolic interactionism, human interaction is fundamentally social, involving the exchange of meanings shaped by cultural contexts. In this sense, meaningful communication has the potential to transform learning environments by facilitating the exchange of ideas and allowing the development of essential human skills.
The evolution of BL is becoming increasingly evident, shifting the focus from mere technology implementation to the psychosocial processes underlying student interactions. This evolving perspective reflects an emerging research trend in BL, which seeks to address students’ broader educational needs beyond academic performance alone.
Despite the undeniable impact of technology, including AI, on teaching and learning support, these tools cannot replace the processes of shared meaning-making and collaborative knowledge construction among learners. Therefore, it is essential for universities to reinforce these aspects by approaching technology integration as a structured process guided by ethical considerations, which requires the establishment of clear policies that regulate its use and define its scope.
The authors express their gratitude to Jorge Armando Bedoya, Diego Villada Osorio, and Luisa María Rojas for their valuable feedback and insightful review of this paper.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Vittoria Angélica Gómez Martínez: led the conception and design of the study, data collection, theoretical framework, data analysis and interpretation, methodology, and manuscript writing. Martha Lucía García Naranjo contributed as a co-researcher, participating in the discussion, development of the theoretical and methodological framework, and manuscript writing.